The Los Angeles Dodgers are facing criticism regarding their management of Shohei Ohtani's knee injury, with concerns that the team may be pushing the superstar player too hard.
Ohtani has reportedly experienced increasing discomfort in his knee, initially stating he could pitch through it and later insisting he could still perform as the designated hitter. Manager Dave Roberts acknowledged Ohtani's desire to play, noting the player wanted to participate in a game against the Seattle Mariners. However, Ohtani did not play in a subsequent game, though Roberts expressed confidence in his return to the lineup soon after.
The team's approach has been described as potentially "reckless" and "negligent" by some observers. While Roberts has defended the organization's decisions, citing a trust in Ohtani's judgment and pain tolerance, the situation raises questions about player safety versus team performance.
Roberts mentioned that the Dodgers have a history of allowing players, including Freddie Freeman, to play through injuries. He stated that players are treated fairly but individually, and that Ohtani understands the importance of the upcoming parts of the season and his value to the team. Ohtani alerted the Dodgers to his renewed discomfort after a game on Wednesday, which Roberts cited as an example of good communication.
Despite Ohtani's contributions as a productive player even with the knee issue, the recurring discomfort has led to calls for him to be placed on the injured list for a 10-day shutdown. The argument is that Ohtani's own instincts for self-preservation, fueled by his love for the game and high pain tolerance, might be detrimental in this instance. Critics suggest that the Dodgers could show Ohtani greater respect by making the difficult decision to bench him, ensuring he is at his best for the postseason, particularly in October, regardless of short-term discomfort for the team.