The cult classic 'Practical Magic' has a sequel, 'Practical Magic 2,' arriving 28 years after the original, but critics suggest the follow-up fails to recapture the charm and magic that endeared fans to the first film. The film, starring Nicole Kidman and Sandra Bullock, is described as a "wretched sequel" that is "cursed" and lacks any appeal beyond the star power of its leads. The original 1998 film, though considered a flop by some, is noted for having some charm, a quality entirely absent in the new installment.
Directed by Susanne Bier, 'Practical Magic 2' is criticized for its poor writing and editing, making for an often awkward viewing experience. Jokes fall flat, and the pacing is described as glacial, with a runtime of two hours and 10 minutes, longer than its predecessor. The plot centers on the Owens women and a curse that causes any man they fall in love with to die, a curse that was thought to be resolved in the first movie.
The sequel introduces Sally's (Bullock) daughters, Kylie (Joey King) and Antonia (Maisie Williams), who have been magically made to forget their powers. The narrative progresses with Kylie traveling to England to break the family curse after her boyfriend is involved in an accident. The film's dialogue is filled with generic empowerment messages such as "Live a little, live a lot," and "No magic is stronger than sisterhood."
Ian Wright (Lee Pace), a professor of magic history, is introduced but reportedly contributes little to the story. The film's plot is further criticized for relying on hastily explained shortcuts and a predictable twist. The performances of Kidman and Bullock are described as performative, with their celebrity radiating an "impenetrable shield" that hinders viewer immersion. The younger cast members, Williams and King, are noted as having limited material to work with.