Columnist Quentin Letts has analyzed Andy Burnham's political suitability for a potential prime ministerial role, drawing on Burnham's co-authored book "Head North" and past parliamentary experience. The review, published in the Daily Mail, suggests Burnham's temperament may not be suited for the highest office, particularly in comparison to international figures.
Letts highlights Burnham's upbringing and political awakening, influenced by the "Boys From The Blackstuff" television drama and the Hillsborough disaster. The book "Head North" reportedly emphasizes Burnham's emotional intelligence and his articulation of regional grievances, particularly concerning what he perceives as a "London-centric" Establishment's indifference to the North-West of England. This narrative, Letts notes, has been politically effective for Burnham.
However, the review questions Burnham's portrayal as a rebel, contrasting it with his career trajectory. Burnham, who studied at Cambridge and worked as a trade journalist in London before entering Parliament, held several junior ministerial positions between 2005 and 2010, serving under Prime Ministers Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. The review points out that both Blair and Brown's memoirs contain only fleeting references to Burnham, and David Cameron's memoir notes his 2015 leadership bid, describing him as "less quick on his feet" than a rival.
Letts recalls Burnham from his time as a parliamentary sketch writer as an "amiable, uncontroversial middler" who avoided confrontation. The review also touches on an instance where Burnham had to apologize to human rights campaigner Shami Chakrabarti for a mistaken assertion.
Despite Burnham's stated desire for a "more collaborative politics," the review suggests his approach, as detailed in "Head North," can be idealistic and contradictory. It points to his admissions of "Impostor Syndrome" and his critiques of "unelected cliques" while engaging in his own political alliances. The review also questions his stance on education and the European Union, highlighting perceived inconsistencies.
"Head North" co-authored with Mayor of Liverpool Steve Rotheram, is described as a quick but hackneyed read, whose strengths lie in its emotional depth. Yet, the reviewer suggests that Burnham's self-presentation within the book may not align with the robust leadership required for prime minister, especially when facing formidable international figures. The article concludes by questioning whether voters will find Burnham a suitable alternative to current leadership once the initial novelty wears off.