New York State Assemblywoman Emily Gallagher's recent comments suggesting that shoplifters may have a "biological need" to steal have ignited strong criticism from readers of the New York Post. The remarks, which have been interpreted by some as a justification for shoplifting, have prompted a wave of letters to the editor expressing dismay and anger.
Critics argue that Gallagher's statements, if accurate, could have severe repercussions for businesses and communities. "Allowing shoplifting will cause stores to close due to financial losses," wrote Jackie Biaggi of The Bronx. "This will permit the government to take over. Socialist mission accomplished."
Several readers questioned Gallagher's understanding of the economic realities faced by retail workers and business owners. Jim Kilduff of Rockville Centre stated, "She advocates that in some circumstances it’s justified to shoplift. I wonder if she would feel the same way if she had to earn a living working in retail rather than being paid by New York state taxpayers."
Others characterized Gallagher's stance as hypocritical and out of touch. Patricia Keane of Eastport pointed to Gallagher's salary of over $142,000, juxtaposing it with a GoFundMe she reportedly launched for her cat's emergency surgery. "This is a lawmaker who thinks stealing soap and toothpaste should be allowed. No wonder so many are fleeing New York. It is disgraceful."
Yakov Moshe of Brooklyn suggested that Gallagher and her colleagues should focus on other pressing issues, such as "a failed educational system, crime in minority neighborhoods, drugs and more," rather than condoning theft.
The sentiment that Gallagher's views align with a broader anti-law enforcement agenda was expressed by Robert Neglia of The Bronx, who wrote, "A country ruled by law is unacceptable to DSA operatives. Therefore, it must be eliminated in phases. They’ve already started the process."
Some correspondents offered alternative solutions, with Alfred Bonnabel of Manhattan suggesting, "If you are committed to this cause, I respectfully suggest that you consider utilizing personal funds to purchase and distribute these items directly, rather than pursuing your current legislative or policy approach."
Gallagher's position has been met with a mix of disbelief and anger. Mindy Rader of New City asked, "Why should companies make money? I would like to see people explain how one can vote for someone who says this. How do we elect people like this, with these kinds of ideas?"
Sylvia Kane of Brooklyn questioned the electoral process that brought Gallagher to office, suggesting, "Maybe an IQ test should be required to vote. It’s time to take out the trash from the Assembly."
Carol Meltzer of Manhattan offered a more direct critique: "Hey, crazy lady, here is an idea: If you want to brush your teeth, get a job and buy toothpaste. Does Gallagher want the government to come to people’s homes and put deodorant under their armpits for them?"
These letters reflect a strong backlash against the assemblywoman's controversial statements, with many readers calling for accountability and a re-evaluation of who is elected to public office.