Mayor Zohran Mamdani's new initiative aimed at assisting small businesses has drawn criticism, with opponents labeling it a "bait-and-switch" that favors street food vendors over more conventional small businesses.
The plan, presented as a list of "50 regulatory reforms that will transform how government works with small businesses," reportedly dedicates more than half of its provisions to street food vendors. Critics contend that much of the remaining agenda involves minor adjustments, such as extending permit renewal periods for barbers from one to three years or consolidating food allergy posters for restaurants.
Some proposed reforms are described as vague, including vows to "reinforce excellence in customer service" and to broaden the distribution of a "Business Owner Bill of Rights." The core of the criticism centers on the plan's focus on a small sector that generates minimal tax revenue while directly competing with brick-and-mortar establishments that employ staff and pay taxes. The article notes concerns about street food vendors' environmental practices, such as discharging grease into sewer systems, operating gas-powered generators, and using charcoal in open air.
Additionally, the city is reportedly preparing to increase the total number of food vendors. Mamdani's administration is said to be considering amnesty for illegal food vendors with accumulated fines, allowing them to obtain permits without settling their outstanding debts. Proposals also include easing regulations for soft-serve ice cream machine operators, despite concerns about hygiene risks associated with these machines.
The mayor's campaign had previously focused on addressing "halaliflation," the rising cost of halal food cart staples like chicken and rice. While acknowledging the intent to address campaign promises, critics argue that the current plan does not represent a substantial pro-small-business agenda.