The highly anticipated Manchester Derby is set to feature a combined XI based on statistical performance from the 2025-26 season thus far, with Manchester City players dominating the lineup. The fixture, which traditionally pits local rivals against each other, will see City under the management of Enzo Maresca, while Manchester United is led by permanent boss Michael Carrick.
City has commenced the new season with strong victories against Crystal Palace, Bournemouth, and Coventry, while United has experienced a slower start, accumulating only four points in their initial three matches.
Goalkeeper and Defense
In goal, Gianluigi Donnarumma of Manchester City secures the spot. Donnarumma, who joined City on transfer deadline day in 2025, recorded the second-highest number of clean sheets in the league last season with 15. His SofaScore rating is 7.70.
The defensive line is exclusively comprised of Manchester City players. Right back Abdukodir Khusanov, who joined in January 2025, is noted for his athleticism and speed, contributing to City's possession-based style with an average of 72% possession this season. His SofaScore rating is 7.73. At center back, City captain Ruben Dias, a consistent performer since 2020-21, earns a place with a rating of 7.63. Alongside him is Marc Guehi, a cost-effective signing from Crystal Palace in 2025-26 who proved instrumental in City's title challenge with his composure and ability to advance play, holding a rating of 7.80. The defensive unit is completed by left back Josko Gvardiol, who has impressed with his physicality and attacking contributions, recording 16 goal involvements in 86 Premier League games for City. His SofaScore rating is 7.17.
Midfield
The midfield sees a blend of both Manchester clubs. Manchester United's Kobbie Mainoo is the first United player to feature, noted for his exceptional dribbling and agility, earning a SofaScore rating of 7.37. He is joined by Manchester City's Elliot Anderson, who arrived from Nottingham Forest for a club-record fee of £116m after a standout season. Anderson's ability to cover ground and his passing range make him a valuable asset in a possession-dominant team, with a rating of 7.70. The third midfield spot goes to Manchester City's Enzo Fernandez. Despite playing only one game this season after a record-breaking £125m transfer, Fernandez is recognized for his aggressive approach, long-range shooting, and high work rate. His SofaScore rating is 7.30.
Attack
In attacking midfield, Rayan Cherki of Manchester City has made a notable impact this season, demonstrating flair and dribbling ability. His SofaScore rating is 7.73. Manchester United's captain, Bruno Fernandes, is also included following a strong start to the season, including a hat-trick. With four goal involvements in three games and a record 21 assists last season, Fernandes is a key playmaker for United, holding a SofaScore rating of 7.80.
Leading the line is Manchester City's Erling Haaland. The prolific striker has already scored three goals in three appearances this season and boasts a strong record in Manchester derbies. His pace and power make him a constant threat, and he tops the combined XI with the highest SofaScore rating of 7.90.
The last derby meeting between these two sides saw Manchester United win 2-0 at Old Trafford, a match that marked Pep Guardiola's final derby in charge of City and Michael Carrick's first as interim manager. Goals from Bryan Mbeumo and Patrick Dorgu secured the victory in that encounter.