A state-funded Irish charity, Cuidiú, has drawn criticism for promoting a monthly event titled ‘breastfeeding/chestfeeding group,’ which a politician argues uses "insulting nonsense." Peadar Tóibín TD, leader of the Aontú party, stated that the Health Service Executive (HSE), which provides at least €30,000 in funding to Cuidiú, appears to be "driving this crackpot ideology."

Tóibín asserted that "chestfeeding isn’t a thing" and that only women can breastfeed, expressing concern that professionals in women's health are hesitant to state these "scientific facts." He criticized the "eradication of female-specific language" in the name of "inclusion and equality," calling it an "insult to women and in particular, to nursing mothers."

This controversy follows a separate incident involving the Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI). The ALCI's annual conference, which also received HSE funding, faced backlash over a scheduled speaker who had previously discussed "lactation for kinksters" at fetish conventions. The speaker, Jacob Engelsman, wrote in his book, "Lactation For The Rest Of Us: A Guide For Queer And Trans Parents And Helpers," that men may desire to lactate for reasons including "sexual gratification."

Following the criticism and threat of protests, the ALCI announced that its October conference would be held entirely online, citing health and safety concerns. The organization also indicated that Engelsman might be removed from the program and stated its intention to "endeavour in the future" to hold educational events supporting the "LGBT community and diversity" on lactation.

The ALCI acknowledged member feedback and recognized a need for "greater clarity and more regular communication." Jill Nesbitt of Women’s Space Ireland, an organization that planned to protest, called the idea of men attempting to lactate to feed a baby "child abuse," stating, "A baby can’t consent to being used as a prop for a man’s sexual fetish."

Cuidiú's website states that while they generally use the terms "mother/mum," they acknowledge that not all individuals who breastfeed or chestfeed their babies identify as women. The organization states it is "inclusive" and supports "all parents in their feeding method of choice."

According to Cuidiú's 2021 annual report, the organization received approximately €30,000 from the HSE and the National Lottery. The report noted its dependence on grant aid, memberships, training course fees, and donations.

Both Cuidiú and the HSE were contacted for comment regarding the controversy.