Prosecutors have declined to press criminal charges against Carlos Suarez-Contreras, an undocumented immigrant accused of fatally striking 82-year-old Deborah Murphy with his SUV in a grocery store parking lot in Panama City Beach, Florida. The decision, announced nearly six months after the May 17 incident, has left Murphy's daughters demanding accountability and questioning the investigation.

Suarez-Contreras was reversing his Toyota 4Runner at a Publix grocery store when he hit Murphy as she walked back to her car with groceries. An arrest affidavit stated that the SUV knocked Murphy to the ground and continued in reverse, crushing her. She was transported to a hospital with severe injuries and died shortly after.

State Attorney Larry Basford stated that while Suarez-Contreras's actions were "careless and negligent," the evidence did not meet the threshold required to secure a conviction for a crime. "Not every tragedy amounts to a crime," Basford told Fox News Digital.

Suarez-Contreras, a 26-year-old from Venezuela, had initially been arrested on charges of driving with a canceled license and causing death. His Georgia driver's license had been canceled one day prior to the collision. However, prosecutors said they could not prove Suarez-Contreras was aware his license had been canceled, a crucial element for prosecution under Florida law. The Georgia Department of Driver Services confirmed the cancellation but did not specify when Suarez-Contreras was notified.

Charges of vehicular homicide and manslaughter were also considered but ultimately dismissed. Investigators determined, based on surveillance footage and collision reconstruction, that the SUV was not reversing at a speed sufficient to meet the "culpable negligence" standard required for such charges under Florida law. A 2023 Florida law that invalidates certain out-of-state licenses issued to undocumented immigrants could not be applied in this case, as Georgia was not among the states covered by the legislation.

Murphy's daughters, Amy Edge and Beth Schulz, expressed dismay and a sense of betrayal by the state's decision. They questioned why Suarez-Contreras was not tested for drugs or alcohol and why his cellphone records were not examined. The daughters also dispute the reconstruction findings, asserting that Suarez-Contreras "drove backwards" and never stopped or attempted to aid their mother.

Suarez-Contreras was transferred to the custody of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) on November 15. His attorney expressed satisfaction with the dropping of criminal charges. The victim's daughters are now focused on ensuring Suarez-Contreras is deported, stating they do not want him to be able to cause similar harm to others in the United States. They are also exploring legislative changes to prevent similar outcomes in future fatal traffic collisions.

Luis Sanabria, 29, identified as an illegal immigrant from Venezuela and the SUV's passenger, had an expired visa and was released into ICE custody after initially fleeing the scene and later identifying Suarez-Contreras as the driver. Murphy, a retired educator, is survived by her husband, two daughters, six grandchildren, and one great-grandchild.