Catherine Schuster, the first manager of The Motley Coffeehouse at Scripps College, has announced she will no longer support her alma mater due to what she calls a pattern of antisemitism and a failure to maintain an inclusive campus environment. The dispute intensified when students were told to fly U.S. and Israeli flags of equal size to a large Palestinian flag they had displayed.
In response to the college's directive, the student staff voted to remove the Palestinian flag entirely, a decision that Schuster criticizes as an abdication of inclusivity. She told the California Post that if a space is not inclusive of everyone, it should not exist. Schuster, a graduate from the class of 1978, expressed that the college has changed for the worse since her time, stating that Scripps has failed to ensure campus spaces are welcoming to Jewish students.
Schuster communicated her concerns in a letter to the college president and trustees on December 18, 2025, but reported receiving no response. She stated that while individuals have the right to their beliefs, they should not exclude others from discussion. She believes that if similar situations had involved other minority groups, such as Hispanic or Black students, they would not have been tolerated.
The flag controversy is one of several incidents that prompted Schuster to voice her concerns. She cited a federal civil rights complaint filed in 2025 by the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, the Anti-Defamation League, and the law firm Arnold & Porter with the U.S. Department of Education. This complaint accused Scripps of not adequately protecting Jewish and Israeli students from harassment and discrimination, alleging a hostile campus environment had been allowed to develop.
Incidents mentioned in the complaint and by Schuster include an alleged instance of a student being told to remove a Star of David necklace, the display of a Palestinian flag at The Motley while an Israeli flag was refused, and the absence of a vigil for victims of the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack. The complaint also noted an alleged disparity in disciplinary actions between Scripps students involved in protests and those at neighboring Pomona College.
Schuster recalled her time at Scripps as academically rigorous and politically neutral, contrasting it with the current climate. She remembers professors holding office hours at the coffeehouse and a focus on studies rather than political displays. She feels that the college's actions and inactions have created an environment where Jewish students may feel excluded.
Schuster, who helped establish The Motley Coffeehouse during her undergraduate years, said she is now in a position to make significant financial contributions to her alma mater but has no intention of doing so unless the college acknowledges its perceived mistakes. Scripps College did not immediately respond to requests for comment.