Teachers in the UK have reportedly been given official permission to use AI chatbots, such as ChatGPT, for marking exam coursework. This guidance, issued by the Joint Council for Qualifications (JCQ), has drawn sharp criticism from educationalists who describe the move as "nothing short of scandalous" and "preposterous."

The development comes despite strict warnings and penalties for students found using AI to create their coursework. Dr. Will Van Reyk, Director of Innovation at St. Paul's School in London, where AI marking is banned, argues that the guidance "crosses a red line that should never be crossed." He expressed concern that the exam regulator, Ofqual, is "losing its grip" by allowing AI in marking when students face repercussions for its misuse.

"It basically gives the green light for teachers to put coursework into AI with the small caveat a human oversees the final mark but why are they even allowing that when AI can't do the marking and has no place in marking?" Dr. Van Reyk questioned. He highlighted that there are currently no restrictions on which AI tools teachers can use and that educators have not received specific training for these applications. "These are not even specialist chatbots - what they would feed students' coursework into are just standard bots like ChatGPT or Microsoft Copilot," he noted, emphasizing a lack of evidence that mainstream AI chatbots are suitable for marking.

Dr. Van Reyk also pointed out that the guidance appears to contradict statements made by Education Secretary Lucy Powell, who has stated her belief that AI has no place in marking. He believes the JCQ guidance is "buried" within a 55-page document focusing primarily on students' use of AI, with insufficient standards for teachers.

"The kids and parents do not know if that coursework went through AI and that is allowed in the current system. For me that means coursework at both ends is totally invalid now because you've got kids writing the coursework with AI and teachers allowed to mark it with AI, albeit not as the final marker," he stated.

A JCQ spokesperson asserted that its guidance is "consistent with the regulator's position and is clear that AI must not take over the marking of students' work." They added that AI must not be used as the primary or sole means of marking, and the guidance will be updated according to further input from the regulator.

Similarly, an Ofqual spokesperson reiterated that AI cannot be used as the sole marker in any assessment for a regulated qualification, stressing the continued necessity of human involvement, oversight, and accountability. A DFE spokesperson added that AI should never replace a teacher's professional judgment and assessments must be conducted by the teacher. While acknowledging AI's potential to reduce teacher workload, they reinforced that it cannot be the sole or primary mechanism for determining student marks, and that the department is working to ensure the fairness and reliability of qualifications.