Teachers in the UK have been given official permission to use artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots to assist in marking exam coursework, a development that critics have labeled "nothing short of scandalous." The Joint Council for Qualifications (JCQ), which oversees UK exam boards, has reportedly issued guidance allowing educators to employ AI tools such as ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot for marking, a move that educationalists argue contradicts warnings given to students about the use of AI in creating coursework.

Dr. Will Van Reyk, Director of Innovation at St. Paul's School in London, where AI marking is banned, criticized the guidance as "preposterous" and a violation of a crucial boundary. He expressed concern that the exam regulator Ofqual is "losing its grip" by permitting AI in marking while simultaneously cracking down on students' AI use. "It basically gives the green light for teachers to put coursework into AI with the small caveat a human oversees the final mark but why are they even allowing that when AI can't do the marking and has no place in marking?" he stated.

Van Reyk highlighted that there are currently no restrictions on which AI tools teachers can use, nor has specific training been provided. He argued that mainstream AI chatbots are not designed for academic marking and that allowing their use could lead to "dodgy marks." He also noted that the guidance on AI use in assessments, a 55-page document from JCQ, appears to bury this permission while focusing heavily on how students should acknowledge AI use. This situation, he warned, makes coursework "totally invalid" as both students and teachers may be using AI.

Critics like Dr. Van Reyk contend that the use of AI in marking undermines the student-teacher relationship and creates a "vicious cycle" where it is difficult to dissuade students from using AI for their own work. "For me that means coursework at both ends is totally invalid now because you've got kids writing the coursework with AI and teachers allowed to mark it with AI, albeit not as the final marker," he said.

A spokesperson for JCQ stated that its guidance is "consistent with the regulator's position and is clear that AI must not take over the marking of students' work." They emphasized that AI cannot be used as the primary or sole means of marking and that the guidance aligns with the regulator's requirements.

Ofqual reiterated its stance that AI may not be used as the sole marker in any assessment for a regulated qualification, stressing the necessity of expert human involvement. A Department for Education (DfE) spokesperson added that AI must never replace a teacher's professional judgment and that assessments must be undertaken by the teacher. While acknowledging AI's potential to reduce teacher workload, the DfE stated it cannot be used as the sole or primary mechanism for determining marks, and that the department is working to ensure fairness and reliability in qualifications.