Christopher Nolan's new $250 million film, "The Odyssey," is generating buzz, but actor Tom Holland's performance as Telemachus has become a focal point for critical debate. While reviews for Nolan's 13th feature have been largely positive, some critics have voiced concerns about the film's modernized dialogue and Holland's casting.
Holland, who plays the son of Odysseus (portrayed by Matt Damon), described the role as "one of the toughest jobs I've had." The British actor's use of contemporary language, including the word "dad," has been a particular point of contention. Danny Leigh of the Financial Times found Holland's delivery jarring, writing that the actor "is comic-book basic" and that the contemporary "dad" felt out of place in the ancient setting. Similarly, David Rooney of The Hollywood Reporter stated that while Holland is an "appealing screen presence," he is "wrong for the role," noting that his "American accent" and perceived Peter Parker persona detract from Telemachus's gravitas.
Stephanie Zacharek of Time called Holland "so bland he’s practically unreadable," and Hoai-Tran Bui of Inverse suggested that Holland's Telemachus "suffers from being just fine," serving primarily as a foundation for more prominent performances.
However, not all critics were unfavorable. Gregory Nussen of Deadline offered a contrasting view, labeling Holland's performance as "his strongest one to date." Nussen observed that Holland's portrayal, while tinged with "courageous naivety," demonstrated "newfound maturity."
Nolan has defended his decision to modernize the dialogue, aiming for language with "emotional not intellectual meaning." He admitted to potentially being "naïve" but desired an "earthy narrative." Holland, in turn, defended the use of "dad," arguing it was as accurate as "father" would have been, given the historical context.
Holland was reportedly persuaded to take the role by his wife and co-star Zendaya, who jokingly threatened to leave him if he declined. He successfully negotiated with Sony Pictures to shift production dates for "Spider-Man," allowing him to participate in "The Odyssey."