The new musical "Sinatra: The Musical," currently playing at London's Aldwych Theatre, has received a mixed reception, with critics praising its vocal performance while lamenting its superficial portrayal of the legendary crooner. The production, which is booking until April 2027, aims to chronicle Frank Sinatra's life, from his humble beginnings as the son of Sicilian immigrants to his status as a global icon.
Joel Harper-Jackson, who stars as Sinatra, has been singled out for his vocal performance, which is described as "intoxicating" and capable of capturing "every nuance and vocal trick" of the singer. He delivers over 20 of Sinatra's hits, including "My Way" and "New York, New York." His rendition of "That's Life" is noted as a show-stopping moment, particularly as it accompanies the depiction of Sinatra's affair with Ava Gardner, played by Anna Villafane.
Despite the strong musical numbers, the production has been criticized for not delving into Sinatra's more challenging personal aspects. Reviews suggest the musical "borders on air-brushing" and "never get[s] under the skin" of the singer. While Sinatra's career was marked by significant events, including his relationships with Nancy Sinatra, Ava Gardner, Mia Farrow, and Barbara Marx, and his eventual comeback with an Oscar win for "From Here To Eternity," the musical reportedly omits details such as his suspected association with the Mafia.
Kathleen Marshall's production features "razzmatazz" and "immaculately tailored" costumes, which some find contribute to a "thoroughly plastic" and "synthetic" feel. Supporting performances include Phoebe Panaretos as Sinatra's first wife, Nancy, and Felicity Watson as his daughter, "Moonbeam." Lee Zarrett plays Sinatra's exasperated publicist, George Evans.
Ultimately, the musical is presented as a "3D jukebox" experience that may satisfy audiences looking for a vibrant musical revue, but may leave those seeking a deeper insight into Frank Sinatra's complex life wanting more.