The new musical "Sinatra: The Musical" at London's Aldwych Theatre has received a mixed reception, with critics praising its vocal performances while noting a lack of emotional depth and a tendency to sanitize the legendary singer's life. The production, which features over 20 of Frank Sinatra's hits, aims to chronicle his journey from the son of immigrants to a global icon.
Joel Harper-Jackson, in the titular role, has been highlighted for his vocal delivery, described as "intoxicating" and capable of capturing Sinatra's distinctive style. His rendition of "That's Life" is noted as a standout moment, particularly when depicting Sinatra's tumultuous affair with Ava Gardner. However, despite Harper-Jackson's performance, the show is criticized for not delving beneath the surface of the singer's persona.
The musical touches on significant life events, including Sinatra's relationships with Nancy Barbato, Ava Gardner, Mia Farrow, and Barbara Marx, as well as his career resurgence after winning an Oscar for "From Here To Eternity." Yet, darker aspects of his life, such as alleged Mafia connections, are largely omitted.
Kathleen Marshall's direction and the show's choreography contribute to a "razzmatazz" that, for some critics, keeps the narrative on a superficial level. Supporting roles, such as Phoebe Panaretos as Nancy Sinatra and Lee Zarrett as his publicist George Evans, add touches of humor and character.
Despite the criticisms of being "air-brushed" and "plastic," the show is expected to appeal to audiences seeking a "3D jukebox" experience. "Sinatra: The Musical" is scheduled to run until April 2027.
