The New York Post reviewed and sweat-tested 21 workout-clothing brands to identify the best options for women across a range of activities and budgets. After in-person wear tests, customer-review research and material assessments, the publication named lululemon its overall pick while awarding category honors to brands such as Fanka for high-performance support and Girlfriend Collective for plus-size and sustainable options.
Reporters and commerce editors evaluated brands for material, style and fit, then put garments through real workouts including HIIT, running, yoga and strength training. The testing emphasized how garments performed under sweat and movement, with attention to durability, breathability, support and available size ranges. The review was written by Miska Salemann, a commerce reporter for the New York Post, who noted differences in fabric technology, sizing options and price points across the field.
lululemon was named the best overall brand for women’s workout clothing. Reviewers cited the company’s broad size range, multiple inseam options and fabrics that balance a “barely there” feel with lasting performance. The brand’s Align leggings and Align bra scored highly for comfort and fit, and lululemon’s resale and sale sections also received mention as ways to offset higher price points. The brand offers leggings in sizes 0 to 20, multiple inseam lengths, standard and expedited shipping, and a 30-day return policy for online or in-store purchases.
Fanka received the award for “best for a serious sweat” due to its PowerLift technology and kinesiology-driven design intended to provide joint and muscle support. The brand’s garments incorporate zoned tension and moisture-wicking fabrics and include features such as multiple pockets and reversible leggings. Testers reported reduced post-workout soreness after high-intensity classes. Fanka offers sizes from XS to 4XL, free and standard shipping options, and a 30-day return window.
Quince, praised as a strong option for activewear basics, was noted for using eco-friendly materials like recycled polyester and Tencel, offering three inseams for leggings and delivering minimalistic designs at lower price points than many competitors. Carbon38, recommended as the most fashionable pick, was highlighted for elevated silhouettes and premium materials though reviewers flagged higher price tags and a limited size range.
Glowmode was flagged as a budget-friendly brand that delivers flattering fits and durable fabrics, with many items priced under $25. Alo Yoga earned recognition for yoga and pilates, drawing attention for celebrity endorsements, a broad range of styles for multiple workouts and high-quality fabrics; testers cautioned that some pieces run tight and may require sizing up.
NEIWAI was named the best splurge, recommended for understated, mix-and-match neutrals and a women-led design approach that includes specialty items for dancers and ballet enthusiasts. Reviewers advised that some NEIWAI pieces require delicate care and that buyers may need to size up on certain items.
Vuori’s reputation for soft, breathable materials and durable construction made it the most comfortable pick in the review. The brand’s DreamKnit collection and cloud-soft joggers were singled out for longevity and everyday wearability. Free People’s FP Movement line was recommended for low- to medium-impact workouts and outerwear, and Girlfriend Collective was cited as the best plus-size option for its recycled fabrics, extended sizing to 6XL and the brand’s Re-Girlfriend recycling program.
L*Space was recognized for combining activewear and swimwear silhouettes with modern cuts and removable bra cups, while Gymshark was noted for value-driven pieces, viral scrunch leggings and student discounts. NOBULL received praise for lightweight, well-constructed garments and a wide selection of training shoes, and Under Armour was recommended for high-impact and sport-specific gear, including infrared and compression technologies.
P.E Nation was recommended for winter and street-to-slope versatility, and Outdoor Voices was singled out for technical outdoor fabrics and RecTrek pants designed for hiking and multi-season use. Fabletics earned a spot as the best cheap option due to its membership model and deeply discounted VIP pricing, with a caveat about occasional durability and sizing inconsistencies. Set Active was noted for high-compression smoothing fabrics for those seeking strong hold, and CALIA was highlighted for running-friendly features such as UPF sun protection and odor-control technology.
Terez stood out for vibrant colors and patterns as a “cute” option, while Aerie and other budget-friendly labels were recognized for accessible pricing and inclusive sizing. The New York Post’s testing process included assessing materials commonly used in athleticwear (nylon, spandex, elastane, mesh), evaluating garments intended for different impact levels, and verifying advertised features such as moisture-wicking, quick-dry, and compression.
The review also reported on practical shopping details supplied by brands: typical size ranges varied from limited offerings such as XS–L at some fashion-forward labels to extended ranges like XXS–6XL at sustainability-focused brands. Return policies ranged from 14 days for some premium lines to 365-day windows for qualifying items at Quince, with many major brands offering 30- to 120-day return periods. Shipping options similarly ranged from free ground over a dollar threshold to paid expedited services.
The Post said shoppers should consider workout type, desired support level and fit when choosing among brands. High-intensity athletes may prioritize compression and durable nylon blends, while yoga practitioners often value breathability and stretch. Reviewers emphasized checking inseam and size options and reading brand-specific fit notes; several brands recommend sizing up for tighter-waisted or highly compressive materials.
The New York Post’s shopping and testing coverage is authored by a commerce reporter who conducted hands-on wear tests alongside consumer-review analysis. The review is intended to help readers weigh performance, price and sustainability trade-offs when updating workout wardrobes and to point buyers toward brands that match their activity levels and aesthetic preferences.