The film "Tony" examines the early life of acclaimed chef and writer Anthony Bourdain, tracing his aspirations for culinary success back to his time in Provincetown. The movie portrays Bourdain, as depicted by actor Sessa, as an arrogant and dishonest young man, even fabricating a story about writing a book to impress someone named Nancy.

This portrayal is informed by Bourdain's own candid reflections on his younger self. In his book "Kitchen Confidential," he described himself as "angry" and "undisciplined," writing that he "treated the world like my ashtray." Director Howe noted that Bourdain's "brutally honest" self-critique allowed the filmmakers "some free rein to paint this wayward young man in all his warts."

According to Alex Getmanov, a chef at The Flagship, Bourdain "didn’t know anything, and he had this attitude that he could do anything, which doesn’t get you far in a working kitchen." Bourdain himself stated that working in The Flagship's kitchen "essentially pushed me down the path I still walk to this day."