The third installment of Netflix's "Enola Holmes" franchise, starring Millie Bobby Brown, has been met with lukewarm reception, with critics pointing to a reliance on formula and a general lack of memorable moments. The film sees Brown reprise her role as the younger sister of Sherlock Holmes, now a professional detective.
In "Enola Holmes 3," the titular character is on the verge of marrying her love interest, Tewkesbury, who has become a British Lord. However, her wedding plans are put on hold when she learns that Sherlock Holmes has been kidnapped. This central plot point sets Enola on a new investigation, which the film weaves with themes of British colonization, family dynamics, and Enola's struggle to balance her independent spirit with traditional societal expectations.
The movie introduces new characters and plotlines, including the return of Enola's mother, Eudoria, played by Helena Bonham Carter, and an appearance by Enola's arch-enemy, Moriarty. The setting shifts to Malta, providing a backdrop for discussions on colonialism and privilege. Despite these elements, critics suggest the film struggles to offer fresh excitement.
Reviewers note that while the "Enola Holmes" films offer a lighter take on detective stories, often compared to "Nancy Drew" with a "Ferris Bueller"-esque charm, the third installment fails to capture the magic of its predecessors. Millie Bobby Brown's performance, while consistent, is described as upbeat but lightweight, with some suggesting she may be reaching the limits of her charisma within the character's established mold. The direct address to the audience, a hallmark of the series, is also noted as potentially becoming an "annoyingly cutesy" element.
The film's attempts at humor are largely ineffective, and its romantic elements are tentative, likely aiming to maintain a PG-13 rating. The narrative is described as workmanlike, moving through a listless story to a drawn-out conclusion. While Helena Bonham Carter's performance injects some energy, and Sharon Duncan-Brewster's portrayal of Moriarty attempts villainous intensity, the overall impact is diminished.
Philip Barantini steps in as director for this installment, aiming to bring a fresh perspective. However, the film's perceived "faux-ambition" in sprinkling in themes of colonization and racism is seen by some as a well-intentioned but ultimately superficial attempt to add depth. The overarching sentiment from critics is that "Enola Holmes 3" suffers from diminishing returns, failing to compel full attention and ultimately earning a "Skip It" recommendation from some outlets.