Holly Willoughby's return to broadcasting with her new YouTube lifestyle show, 'Together,' has drawn criticism for its content and perceived authenticity. A recent column described the show as a "steaming landfill of banality," suggesting it struggles to connect with viewers.
The program features Willoughby engaging in everyday activities, such as cooking with actor Stanley Tucci. During one segment, the pair took 50 minutes to prepare a simple spaghetti dish, a pace the critic deemed slow and unengaging. Willoughby's on-screen persona, described as "caring, sharing" and "relatable," has been questioned, with the columnist noting her estimated wealth of £12 million and the implication of significant personal staff.
Comparisons have been made to Meghan Markle's television efforts, particularly her Netflix series 'With Love.' The article suggests that audiences have seen similar "performative nonsense" before and may not be receptive to another attempt at relatability from a celebrity. The critique highlights instances where Willoughby appeared surprised by common knowledge, such as a bottle of rosé pinot grigio, and Tucci's sometimes condescending explanations of culinary matters.
Willoughby's departure from ITV's 'This Morning' over 30 months prior occurred under difficult circumstances. She and former co-host Phillip Schofield faced criticism in 2022 for allegedly skipping the queue for Queen Elizabeth's lying-in-state. Schofield's subsequent departure from television due to an undisclosed relationship also cast a shadow. More recently, in 2024, a man was jailed for life for plotting to kidnap and murder Willoughby.
Despite these challenges, Willoughby has stated she is unconcerned by public opinion of her new show. 'Together' is unscripted and filmed in a documentary style, employing techniques like shaky camera angles and shots of the production crew. The show includes various segments, such as "Talk Together," where female celebrities discuss personal topics, and "Look Good Together," focusing on fashion and beauty.
The article concludes that while Willoughby and her guests may find satisfaction in the show's content, the overall impression is one of manufactured authenticity, lacking genuine simplicity and taste. The critic implies that such lifestyle programs often prioritize personal gain over substance.