The live-action remake of Disney's animated hit "Moana" has faced a critical backlash, debuting with a 38% positive rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics have lambasted the film for what they describe as a lack of creativity and a poorly executed aesthetic, with some likening its output to AI-generated content.
The original "Moana," released in 2016, was praised for its vibrant animation, engaging story, and popular music, achieving significant commercial success with a worldwide gross of $643 million.
However, early reviews for the 2026 live-action version have been largely negative. The Associated Press review by Jake Coyle noted the film's "purposeless" nature and criticized Dwayne Johnson's appearance as Maui, specifically his wig, describing it as "Fabio hair."
Other critics have described the film as "pointless" and "lifeless," with some suggesting it falls into an "uncanny valley" effect. The visual presentation in trailers has also been criticized for appearing desaturated and uninteresting compared to the animated original.
Fran Drescher, speaking to Fox News Digital at the New York City Ballet Spring Gala 2026, commented on the trend of reboots and sequels, suggesting they can "erode classic legacies." She emphasized the importance of supporting the arts amidst ongoing labor disputes.
Critics suggest that major studios, including Disney, are increasingly relying on remakes and sequels, potentially indicating a decline in original content creation. While the live-action "Moana" may still achieve profitability, the negative reception suggests a growing audience weariness with what are perceived as lesser versions of beloved animated classics.
Dwayne Johnson reprised his role as the demigod Maui, while Auliʻi Cravalho, who voiced the titular character in the original, returned for the live-action version. The film is scheduled for release on July 10, 2026.
