Brooks Nader acknowledged reports that she dated US Open finalists Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner this summer during an appearance on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, saying, “a lady never kisses and tells, especially twice.” She added, “That’s just not nice,” as her sister Grace Ann Nader sat in the audience and quipped, “Especially not to her other boyfriend.”
Nader's remarks followed Page Six’s exclusive report that she dated both players at the same time this summer. A Page Six source said the Love Thy Nader star had dated the No. 1 and No. 2 seeds at the time of this year’s US Open, helping explain why she appeared at the tournament. Grace Ann, 25, had also publicly said at New York Fashion Week that “The rumors are true.”
Nader also noted on WWHL that “dating” is a loose term and said, “My only thing is, guys do it all the time, so why can’t I do it?” Cohen, 57, and guest Mark Ronson cheered and gave Nader a standing ovation for her reply.
The fashion-and-fitness model has been on the market since April following a split from her Dancing With the Stars partner, Gleb Savchenko, whose on‑again, off‑again romance with Nader drew public attention. Savchenko is currently paired with Hilaria Baldwin on the current season of the show. Prior to dating Savchenko, Nader was married to Billy Haire from 2019 until their separation in 2024; their divorce was finalized in May 2025.
Nader’s public dating life has unfolded amid broader tabloid coverage of her personal life, with Page Six reporting that she dated both Alcaraz and Sinner this summer and that she was seen at this year’s US Open in their company. No representatives for the athletes publicly commented on the reports.
No immediate comments were released from Alcaraz’s or Sinner’s camps, and Page Six continues to report on the story with the understanding that all parties involved have kept their comments limited to confirmed statements and appearances.
