The BBC's crime drama "Ludwig," now in its second series, has been described as a "ridiculously twee whodunnit" that blends elements of Hammer Horror with the investigative style of Agatha Christie's Miss Marple. In a review for the Daily Mail, TV critic Christopher Stevens noted that the show's premise treats each murder mystery as a complex brainteaser, akin to a chess problem or a spot-the-difference puzzle.
Last week's episode saw the titular sleuth, played by David Mitchell, declare, "This is absolutely ridiculous!" a sentiment the reviewer suggests many viewers might echo. Mitchell portrays Ludwig as a bumbling, corduroy-clad amateur detective whose investigative methods rely on abstract puzzles. This characterization is compared to his role as loans manager Mark in "Peep Show," highlighting a perceived reliance on a fussy, nervous persona.
The series attempts to combine "Agatha Christie-does-Hammer Horror" with a plot involving the investigation of a local MP suspected of human sacrifices for eternal life. However, Stevens argues that for "cosy crime" to succeed, the character psychology must remain believable, even with outlandish murder scenarios. He finds that "Ludwig" struggles to maintain this balance, with relationships between characters sometimes feeling dictated by plot requirements rather than genuine interaction.
Further criticism is leveled at the show's inconsistent genre blending. A subplot concerning corruption among politicians and high-ranking officials is deemed more suited to a series like "Line Of Duty" than a lighthearted mystery. The reviewer also points out that the police procedural elements falter, with the detective inspector and his team appearing incapable of questioning suspects without Ludwig's intervention. The scene where police officers follow Ludwig when he has a panic attack is cited as an example of this lack of credibility.
Despite these criticisms, the supporting cast is noted for providing substance. Mark Bonnar, as local newspaper editor Gareth Fisher, is credited with offering ballast to the production. Guest stars, such as Gary Beadle and Michelle Greenidge in recent episodes, are described as adding a welcome splash of color to what the reviewer likens to "supermarket prosecco" compared to a more refined offering.