Paul Wilkes, owner of a disused quarry in Corfe Mullen, Dorset, faces a potential £3 million bill to clear an estimated 28,500 tonnes of waste after a recycling firm, Hillier Recycling, allegedly used the site as a dumping ground for seven years. Wilkes had leased the quarry to Hillier Recycling with the understanding that only inert waste like soil and rubble would be deposited.
However, Wilkes discovered within a year that the firm was bringing in a wide range of household rubbish that it had no intention of recycling. Despite reporting concerns to the Environment Agency, the agency issued waste permits to Hillier Recycling. Wilkes states that he repeatedly urged the agency to intervene, but it took six years for the permits to be revoked, during which time lorries continuously deposited waste, creating a 50ft high pile.
"We actually said to the Environment Agency can you please stop them coming and tipping and they said 'don't worry we've got it all in hand' - and nothing happened. The lorries still came," Wilkes told the BBC.
The waste deposited included plastics, electrical items, and hazardous petroleum hydrocarbons, some of which are carcinogenic. Wilkes's employees attempted to block the quarry entrance with a lorry to prevent further dumping, but they were reportedly instructed by the Environment Agency to move it.
Hillier Recycling abandoned the quarry in 2022, and the company later went into liquidation in 2024. The Environment Agency then issued Wilkes with an order to clear the site or face prosecution. He is now appealing this order in court.
Environmental consultants have assessed the waste, estimating the cleanup cost at around £3 million. Rebecca Bomers of Somerton Environmental noted that the Environment Agency should not have granted the permits, citing the lack of an impermeable surface and adequate facilities for waste treatment, which posed a fire risk. She suggested the permit should have been suspended much earlier, particularly in May 2018 when highly combustible waste was stored outside.
Anna Willetts, an environmental lawyer representing the Wilkes family, described the situation as "astounding and absolutely outrageous." She criticized the Environment Agency for allowing the situation to escalate and for placing the burden of the cleanup on the landowner. "It's the Environment Agency's job to protect the environment, they should have shut it down the minute the permits were breached," Willetts stated.
Three men have pleaded guilty to offenses related to the site and are due to be sentenced at Bournemouth Court. The Environment Agency stated it could not comment on active legal proceedings.