Paul Wilkes, owner of a quarry in Corfe Mullen, Dorset, faces an estimated £3 million cleanup bill after a waste operator, Hillier Recycling, dumped approximately 28,500 tonnes of household rubbish and hazardous materials on his land over seven years.

Wilkes had leased the disused quarry to Hillier Recycling with the understanding that only inert waste like soil and rubble would be deposited. However, he discovered the firm was using the site as a dumping ground for a wide range of household waste with no intention of recycling.

Wilkes reported his concerns to the Environment Agency, which subsequently issued permits to Hillier Recycling. Despite the agency's assurances that the matter was under control, it took six years to revoke the company's permits. During this period, Hillier Recycling deposited vast quantities of waste, including plastics, electrical items, and hazardous petroleum hydrocarbons, some of which are carcinogenic, creating piles up to 50ft high.

Wilkes repeatedly appealed to the Environment Agency to shut down the operation. In a desperate attempt to halt further dumping, he had his employees block the quarry entrance with a lorry, but they were instructed by the agency to move it, citing breaches of the lease agreement.

Hillier Recycling abandoned the site in 2022, leaving the enormous waste deposit. The company later went into liquidation in 2024. Following this, the Environment Agency issued Wilkes with an order to clear the site or face prosecution.

Wilkes believes both the recycling company and the Environment Agency are responsible for the situation, stating his company is bearing the cost of the regulator's "incompetence." Environmental consultants assessing the waste have noted that the permits should never have been granted, as the site lacked an impermeable surface to prevent leaching and a building for commercial waste storage, creating a significant fire risk.

According to records, Environment Agency officials visited the site more than 20 times between 2015 and 2022, identifying permit breaches. However, the firm was permitted to continue operating until September 2022. Environmental lawyer Anna Willetts, representing the Wilkes family, described the case as "astounding and absolutely outrageous," emphasizing the agency's failure to act despite multiple warnings.

The Environment Agency has stated it cannot comment on active legal proceedings. Three men have pleaded guilty to offenses related to the site and are awaiting sentencing.