Freeman's Grub & Pub, a restaurant in Greensboro, North Carolina, is standing by its policy to impose a 20% automatic gratuity on customers who repeatedly fail to tip adequately. The policy, which gained attention after an image was shared on Reddit, states that if employees encounter two instances of a customer not tipping well without explanation, the fee will be added to their bill.
The restaurant's policy asserts that 20% or more is the customary tip for restaurant service in the U.S. The policy also notes that receipts will be saved to document instances of poor tipping, and customers are invited to question the charge, though the restaurant maintains that if service was satisfactory, a low tip is unwarranted. The establishment offers a channel to resolve issues if service is not up to par.
The policy has ignited a strong debate online, with many social media users criticizing the restaurant. Comments on Reddit ranged from suggestions to dispute the charge as fraud to vows never to return to the establishment. Others expressed the sentiment that forcing customers to tip is excessive.
In response to the online outcry and a subsequent "review bomb" on platforms like Google and Yelp, Kevin, who co-owns Freeman's with his wife Emily, defended the policy in a video posted on the restaurant's social media. He stated that the staff provides top-tier service and that tips are essential for their livelihood. Kevin emphasized that for a "mom-and-pop joint" like theirs, customers are expected to understand and adhere to tipping norms. He concluded by expressing solidarity with his staff and criticizing those who targeted the restaurant online.
The owners later posted a message thanking the community for their support, quoting the late Anthony Bourdain on the subject of tipping etiquette. The quote read, "If you're a cheap tipper, by the way, or rude to your server, you are dead to me. You are lower than whale feces."