Despite believing they are on Santa's nice list this year, a significant majority of Americans admit to engaging in financially questionable habits during the holiday season, with Gen Z leading the pack in overspending and impulse purchases, according to research. A survey of 2,000 U.S. adults, evenly divided by generation, found that while 70% think they've been good, 79% confessed to "naughty" financial behaviors.

Common transgressions include spending money intended for savings (29%), buying items simply because they were on sale (28%), and paying more for items to receive them sooner (20%). While Gen X (20%) and millennials (18%) were more likely to admit to being on the naughty list, Gen Z exhibited the highest rate of 'naughty' behaviors at 94%, despite 79% believing they were on the nice list.

Gen Z's financial "naughtiness" extends to making impulse purchases over $100 (25%) and waiting too long to act, resulting in higher costs (26%). Nearly one in five (19%) of this demographic admitted to buying something out of jealousy of others' possessions. This trend is expected to continue through the holiday season, with 85% of Gen Z anticipating continued spending in this manner.

Specific 'naughty' behaviors identified in the survey include Gen Z planning to regift items while claiming they are new (21%) and lying about spending amounts (17%). The survey, conducted by Talker Research on behalf of Chime, also highlighted "nice" financial behaviors, such as waiting for sales (34%), prioritizing experiences over material goods (30%), and performing random acts of kindness like paying for a stranger's order (27%).

Many respondents reported positive financial outcomes in 2026, including rising credit scores (31%), unexpected monetary gifts (27%), and having their own expenses covered by others (27%). Nearly three-quarters (73%) believe that receiving rewards for holiday spending would make the experience more valuable. This sentiment drives two-thirds of consumers to plan on using rewards or cashback for holiday purchases, anticipating an average of nearly $250 in rewards and $230 in cashback.

Despite the prevalence of both "nice" and "naughty" spending habits, Americans prioritize certain holiday expenses as always worth the cost: food for meals and baking (36%), gifts (34%), travel for family visits (28%), and holiday decorations (25%). Expenses less deemed essential include matching outfits (25%), visiting Santa (22%), and hosting costs (16%).

According to Janelle Sallenave, Chime’s Chief Spending Officer, most individuals exhibit a mix of financial behaviors, amplified during the holidays. She emphasized the importance of intentional spending and leveraging opportunities like rewards programs. The survey noted that the most worthwhile spending focused on bringing joy to oneself or loved ones, or reducing stress.

The survey also detailed top "nice" financial behaviors, including waiting for sales, focusing on experiences, and paying it forward. Conversely, top "naughty" behaviors involved spending savings, impulse buying, and excessive use of 'Buy Now, Pay Later' options.