A New England woman is challenging the National Park Service's decision to put her family's historic Cape Cod beach shack up for public leasing, decades after the property's ownership was initially seized. Janet Armstrong, a resident of Truro, Massachusetts, has cared for the 'Armstrong Dune Shack' for over 70 years. The National Park Service initiated a request for proposals (RFP) on November 9, opening the property for public leasing. The Armstrong Shack, a two-story seasonal home located within the Peaked Hill Bars National Register Historic District, is subject to a leasing opportunity that the National Park Service states is consistent with the seashore's Dune Shack Historic District Preservation and Use Plan.

Armstrong's parents discovered the shack abandoned in 1948, with broken windows, a hole in the roof, and sand covering the floor. They spent a year locating the owner before purchasing it for their family. In 1961, the Cape Cod National Seashore was established, encompassing the shack's location. The National Park Service first used eminent domain in 1981, granting the Armstrong family a lifetime estate. Following her parents' deaths, Armstrong received a Special Use Permit until the current RFP process began.

She expressed surprise at the announcement, having only learned of it an hour before it became public. The RFP lists the property 'as-is, with all faults' and requires the lessee to manage all repairs and replacements, including updating the 'blackwater waste system' to meet safety codes. The property lacks access to commercial utilities such as electricity, municipal water, or sewer.

Armstrong described the process of applying to remain in her "sacred home" as emotional, given the years she has dedicated to maintaining the shack and surrounding land. She stated that living in the shack has been far from leisurely, citing instances where the access road disappeared due to the ocean and detailing decades of family efforts to maintain the structure and its systems against the elements. She plans to comply with the RFP process in her effort to retain the property.

The public leasing has drawn criticism from advocates concerned about the erosion of multi-generational shack preservation. Michela Murphy, a dune colony advocate, told The Boston Globe that the RFP process risks "erasing the uniqueness of multi-generational shack preservation" and further diminishes a community that has "fought against all odds to survive."

The dune shacks, including the Armstrong Shack, were placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2012. Historically, they have provided refuge for Coast Guardsmen, individuals seeking solitude, and artists and writers inspired by the remote coastal environment. The National Park Service aims to manage these historic properties under a preservation and use plan that protects their significance while allowing for continued occupancy and stewardship. Site tours are scheduled for the week of December 7, with proposals due by January 8, 2027.