Staten Island has become a haven for hundreds of wild turkeys, a population that has grown from an initial release of nine pet birds in 1999. These large birds now frequently halt traffic, commandeer backyards, and have become a significant disruption to the quality of life for many residents.
The turkeys are particularly concentrated around Staten Island University Hospital and adjacent neighborhoods like Ocean Breeze, Dongan Hills, and Arrochar, but their territory has expanded throughout the borough. Drivers often find themselves forced to brake and wait as the birds cross streets, sometimes causing traffic backups for blocks. Videos of drivers expressing frustration with the birds, and even of turkeys chasing residents, have circulated widely.
Residents are divided on how to handle the growing turkey population. Some view them as a unique local feature, while others consider them pests. "They don’t belong in this environment," said Staten Island resident Stephanie Moyle. "The same thing goes for our deer and fox population — Staten Island doesn’t have the space for wildlife."
Others have suggested more drastic measures. One resident, George, told the Staten Island Advance that the birds should be "catch[ed] and take[n] away upstate." Another local, Toni Ann, called them "disgusting" and even suggested poisoning them.
Staten Island Borough President Vito Fossella has described the situation as a persistent headache since the early 2000s. An early attempt to relocate the flock to Maryland was blocked by the State Department of Environmental Conservation because turkeys are not indigenous to that area. Fossella acknowledges that for newcomers, sharing space with these large birds is challenging.
"It’s a mixed bag. Some think they’re neighborhood mascots; others say they’re dirty nuisances and ruining quality of life," Fossella stated. He is open to solutions but also manages other wildlife issues on the island, such as deer and fox populations.
Attempts to manage the turkey population have met with mixed success and ethical debate. In 2013, the U.S. Department of Agriculture considered euthanizing the birds and testing their meat for donation, a proposal that was ultimately rejected. More successful have been relocation efforts, with over 150 turkeys moved to the And-Hof Sanctuary in Catskill between 2014 and 2019.
City wildlife officials recommend a strategy of coexistence, advising residents not to feed the turkeys and to observe them from a distance. They also discourage the birds from nesting on private property.
Despite the challenges, some residents embrace the turkeys. Lifelong Staten Islander Alice Knisley Matthias views them as a tourist attraction and has even witnessed a mother turkey nest and hatch her young in her yard. "When (the turkey) stood up, it was like Mother Ginger in The Nutcracker lifting her skirt — out waddled half a dozen tiny baby turkeys!" she recounted.
Even with some residents welcoming the birds, their presence continues to cause significant disruption. The turkeys, standing up to 3 feet tall and capable of reaching speeds of 25 mph, command respect on the roads, with drivers and pedestrians alike yielding to them. This unexpected wildlife encounter has led to bewilderment and questions on social media, with some even inquiring about hunting the birds, though city regulations prohibit such actions within New York City limits.