A British couple has been awarded 9,000 in compensation after police pepper-sprayed a husband and unlawfully entered their home following a report of a knife found in their front garden.
Sabrina Fearn and her husband Andrew called the police in 2022 after discovering a knife in their garden while hosting friends. Derbyshire Police retrieved the weapon and left, but shortly after, approximately 15 officers returned, demanding to search the property. Ms. Fearn stated she refused entry as the knife was not theirs and she had already shown officers its location.
According to Ms. Fearn, an officer forced the door open, causing her to fall. Her husband then entered the hallway, where two officers allegedly grabbed him by the neck and pepper-sprayed him. He was subsequently taken to a police station and held for 15 hours. Ms. Fearn, who has asthma, was also affected by the pepper spray and taken to the hospital.
Both Sabrina and Andrew Fearn were subsequently charged with assault by beating of an emergency worker. However, the charges were dismissed by a judge in December 2023. The judge reportedly questioned officers about the legality of their entry, with some admitting they were unsure why they entered the property.
Following the dismissal of the criminal charges, the couple filed a civil claim against Derbyshire Police for false imprisonment, injuries sustained, and trespassing. Derbyshire Police issued an apology for the "distress and harm" caused.
A spokesperson for the force admitted that the entry into the property and subsequent actions were unlawful. They stated that at the time, officers believed an injured individual might be present in the house requiring medical attention. The force settled the civil claim, which included allegations of trespass, unlawful arrest, and assault, but did not accept claims of malicious prosecution or negligence.
The couple stated they never received an apology from the force for the incident, and Ms. Fearn expressed trauma, vowing never to call emergency services again.
Derbyshire Police indicated they are reviewing the incident to learn lessons and improve their service, acknowledging that while officers strive to protect the public, they are also human and can make errors. The officers involved were not subject to disciplinary action, and no complaints were made regarding their conduct.