The Scottish National Party (SNP) government has permanently closed its 'supersponsor' scheme for Ukrainian refugees, which had brought nearly 22,000 individuals to Scotland following Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The decision comes after a review highlighted significant challenges in securing adequate accommodation for arrivals, prompting claims that the government prioritized political image over practical planning.

A review led by Professor Linda Bauld found that the scheme was "no longer sustainable in its current form" and recommended its closure to new applicants. Scottish Conservative housing spokesman James Adams criticized the SNP, stating, "The SNP was so desperate to look more generous than the rest of the UK that it made promises it simply couldn’t keep." He added that "Ukrainians are facing homelessness and uncertainty because of a government that put political grandstanding ahead of proper planning."

The shortage of welcome accommodation led the government to use two passenger ships, MS Victoria and MS Ambition, docked in Edinburgh and Glasgow, as temporary housing. While described as "costly," this approach was seen as providing "greater dignity and safeguarding stability compared to alternative emergency models."

The scheme was initially paused in 2022 to ensure existing refugees could be accommodated safely while a review was conducted. Equalities Minister Simita Kumar accepted the review's recommendation to close the scheme to new applicants, emphasizing that the Scottish government remains committed to supporting Ukrainians and that they can still seek sanctuary through the UK's "Homes for Ukraine" scheme.

Professor Bauld's review noted that the "uncapped arrival numbers grew beyond initial projections," exacerbating the accommodation shortage. The prolonged stays in temporary housing, including hotels and ships, had implications for the well-being, independence, and integration of refugees.

Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton expressed disappointment, having previously warned the scheme might not reopen. He pointed to issues such as refugees reporting as homeless, slow vetting of hosts, and a lack of support for local authorities in housing and integrating arrivals.

Minister Kumar acknowledged the review's findings regarding planning and operational delivery, stating that the lessons learned will help shape responses to future humanitarian crises. She expressed gratitude for the "extraordinary" generosity and compassion shown by individuals, communities, organizations, and public services.