Experts have stated there is no proof that the founder of Brown Brasserie and his sister "sped up" the death of their 100-year-old mother by administering a lethal dose of morphine, a murder trial has been told. Pamela Mogford died on February 15, 2022, after her children, restaurateur Jeremy Mogford, 79, and his sister Sarah Pickering, 72, gave her oral morphine solution. However, toxicologists were unable to definitively determine if the quantity of morphine administered was enough to cause her death.
The defendants are accused of giving their mother the equivalent of "at least four times" the amount of morphine prescribed by her GP the evening before she died, with the intention of hastening her death. The siblings acknowledge administering Oramorph after the GP had departed but deny intending to hasten her death, asserting instead that it was to alleviate her pain.
Jurors were informed that because Mrs. Mogford's death initially appeared natural, no post-mortem examination was conducted after her funeral. The siblings' administration of morphine only came to light later when police discovered text messages from Pickering, found on her husband's phone for unrelated reasons, that referred to the morphine administration. Permission was later granted to exhume Mrs. Mogford's coffin for a post-mortem examination in June 2023, more than a year after her burial.
Forensic toxicologist Jefir Sharif testified that morphine, temazepam, and paracetamol were detected in Mrs. Mogford's body during the post-mortem. However, he stated that due to the time elapsed, it was not possible to ascertain the quantity of morphine present at the time of her death. A joint statement from prosecution and defense toxicologists, read to the jury, concluded: "The experts agree that owing to the uncertainties around the samples used for the post-mortem analysis it is not possible to conclude to the required criminal standard that Mrs. Mogford's death had been caused by excess morphine." They further agreed that it was not possible to state, even on the balance of probability, whether additional morphine had been given by any route around the time of her death.
Texts discovered on the evening of Mrs. Mogford's death included messages from Pickering stating, "I am actually killing her" and "I shall wait until Foyle is over then I can go to my grave knowing I have topped someone. It's certainly on my bucket list." Earlier, paramedics had informed Mrs. Mogford's carer that she was unlikely to live much longer after suffering a suspected aneurysm. Mrs. Mogford refused to go to the hospital and died in the early hours of the following day.
Her carer described Mrs. Mogford as appearing "unpresent" with unclear speech the day before she died. Paramedics attending the scene believed she had suffered a suspected abdominal aortic aneurysm and recommended hospital transport, which Mrs. Mogford declined. The carer noted that one of the paramedics indicated Mrs. Mogford was "passing away and he doesn't know how long it will take."
Mrs. Mogford's GP visited her three times that day, administering morphine injections on the second and third visits. The carer’s notes stated Mrs. Mogford was "lying on the bed under morphine in agony." She testified that she would have administered morphine herself out of pity but did not recall doing so and confirmed she would always record such medication in her notes.
Jeremy Mogford, founder of the Browns Brasserie chain, and Pickering are accused of murdering their mother in Bledlow Ridge, Buckinghamshire. They also face an alternative charge of attempted murder. The trial is ongoing.