Experts have stated there is no proof that the founder of Brown Brasserie and his sister "sped up" the death of their 100-year-old mother, a murder trial has heard. Pamela Mogford died on February 15, 2022, after she was given a dose of oral morphine solution by her children, restaurateur Jeremy Mogford, 79, and his sister Sarah Pickering, 72.
However, toxicologists could not conclude that the level of morphine given was enough to kill her. The defendants are accused of giving their mother the equivalent of "at least four times" as much morphine as her GP had given her the evening before she died in an effort to "speed up" her death. The siblings accept giving their mother Oramorph after the GP had left but deny intending to quicken her death, maintaining they did so because she was in pain.
Because Mrs. Mogford's death appeared natural at the time, no post-mortem examination was conducted after her funeral. Her children's administration of morphine only came to light later when police, examining the phone of Pickering's husband for unrelated reasons, discovered messages from Pickering referring to the administration of morphine.
Permission was obtained to exhume Mrs. Mogford's coffin for a post-mortem examination, which took place on June 1, 2023, more than a year after she had been buried. Forensic toxicologist Jefir Sharif told the court that morphine, temazepam, and paracetamol were detected in Mrs. Mogford's body during the examination. However, he added that due to the passage of time, it was not possible to determine the quantity of morphine in her body at the time of her death.
A statement from the prosecution and defense toxicologists read to the jury said: "The experts agree that owing to the uncertainties around the samples used for the post-mortem analysis it is not possible to conclude to the required criminal standard that Mrs. Mogford's death had been caused by excess morphine." The experts also agreed that "it is not possible to state based on the post-mortem result, even on the balance of probability, whether additional morphine via any route had been given around the time of Mrs. Mogford's death."
Paramedics had told Pamela Mogford's carer that she was unlikely to live much longer after suffering a suspected aneurysm at home. Mrs. Mogford refused to go to hospital, dying in the early hours of the following day. Her carer testified that the elderly woman appeared "unpresent" and her speech was unclear the day before she died. When paramedics visited, they believed she had suffered a suspected abdominal aortic aneurysm and recommended hospital transport, which Mrs. Mogford refused.
Jurors heard that Mrs. Mogford's GP visited her three times later that day, giving her injections of morphine on the second and third visits. The carer noted in her records that Mrs. Mogford was "lying on the bed under morphine in agony." The carer stated she would have administered morphine out of pity but did not recall giving any herself and confirmed she would always record medication administered.
Mogford, who founded the Browns Brasserie chain, and Pickering are accused of murdering their mother in Bledlow Ridge, Buckinghamshire. They also face an alternative charge of attempted murder.