A New Jersey man has pleaded guilty to fatally shooting his stepdaughter's French bulldog in the face while dog-sitting for the first time, according to the Ocean County Prosecutor’s Office.
Jeffrey Lentz, 57, initially claimed that Ruby, a 1-year-old dog he and his wife were watching, died in October 2025 from an animal attack. However, a necropsy revealed the wound was from a gunshot, and an X-ray showed a bullet lodged in the dog's jawbone.
Lentz pleaded guilty on Monday to possession of a weapon for an unlawful purpose and animal cruelty. Prosecutors are seeking a five-year prison sentence and a lifetime ban on owning animals.
Ruby's owner, Nicole Guarino, stated that her mother, Lentz's wife, initially told her Ruby had been attacked by another animal. When Guarino arrived with police, her parents reportedly became hostile and handed over the dog in a box, closing the door. Guarino described Ruby as "family" and "like our child."
Lentz was arrested one month after the incident and booked into the Ocean County Jail. His guilty plea will prevent a jury trial. The motive behind the shooting remains undisclosed. Sentencing is scheduled for January 22, 2027, with the state recommending concurrent five-year terms for the weapons offense and three years for the animal cruelty charge.