Five European Union nations have struck an agreement with Rwanda to host failed asylum seekers, mirroring a controversial plan previously pioneered by the United Kingdom. Germany, Austria, Greece, the Netherlands, and Denmark will send asylum seekers with rejected claims to a "return hub" in Rwanda.

This development marks a significant shift, particularly as these nations, along with the UK, had previously faced criticism and legal challenges regarding Rwanda's human rights record when the UK first proposed its plan in June 2022. At that time, judges at the European Court of Human Rights and in London cited concerns about "irreversible harm" and "dismal human rights records," including curbs on free speech and alleged mistreatment in custody, as reasons to block deportations.

The UK's initial plan, which aimed to send all asylum seekers to Rwanda for claim assessments, was scrapped by the Labour government in 2024, with then-Home Secretary Yvette Cooper calling it an "extortionate gimmick" that cost taxpayers approximately £700 million. This included payments to Rwanda, costs for charter flights that never took off, and funding for civil servants.

However, with an estimated 1.33 million illegal migrants entering Europe in the last five years and increasing public pressure to tighten borders, the prospect of sending asylum seekers to a third country appears to have gained traction among EU states. Sue Reid, who covered the initial UK plan from Kigali, notes that the accusations against Rwanda's human rights record seem to have diminished as EU countries face growing immigration challenges.

Reid recounts her experience in 2022, where she reported that potential migrants, including those from Albania preparing to cross the English Channel, stated they would abandon plans to reach Britain if faced with immediate deportation to Rwanda. The prospect of being sent to Rwanda was also reportedly driving migrants to seek entry into Ireland instead of crossing to the UK.

While acknowledging Rwanda may not be a "true democracy" and can be hard-line against dissent, Reid suggests the UK's pioneering plan may have been ahead of its time. The new EU agreements, while differing slightly by focusing on rejected claims rather than initial assessments, fundamentally adopt the same principle.

Concerns remain about the potential consequences for Britain. If the revamped Rwanda deal proceeds, with Europe's "unwanted migrants" potentially facing deportation to Africa, they may increasingly seek to reach the UK. Reid posits that these migrants, having journeyed extensively, are unlikely to return to their home countries and may opt to cross the Channel, especially if Britain is perceived as having abandoned its own deterrent measures. This could ironically lead to more migrants heading to Britain, rather than fewer.

A small boat carrying around 50 migrants drifts into English waters after being trailed by an emergency vessel from the French coastline