A doula from Byron Bay, Amy Lou Smith, is at the center of a coronial inquest into the deaths of four babies born via free births or home births in the region between 2022 and 2024. Smith, who is not medically trained, was paid $2,000 to attend the home birth of a newborn, referred to as Baby DH, on August 16, 2024. The baby died just over eight hours after birth, having been born with a complex heart abnormality.
The parents of Baby DH told police the infant was born appearing purple, with floppy limbs, difficulty breathing, and feeding issues, and had unusual bumps on his chest and tailbone. According to the inquest, Smith allegedly downplayed the parents' concerns on at least five occasions. Shortly after, she reportedly left their home to set up an inflatable jumping castle for her son's birthday party.
Following Smith's departure, Baby DH stopped breathing, and his parents called for an ambulance. The infant was transported to Byron Bay Hospital, where he was pronounced dead. Smith testified at the inquest that the parents were happy for her to leave and that she believed they would have called an ambulance if they had genuine concerns, as she was a non-medically trained doula.
In a podcast interview recorded approximately ten months before Baby DH's death, Smith criticized the medical system, stating it profited from parents' fears and that birth should remain within the community's hands. She stated, "I've heard so many stories about the fear-mongering and the way staff make people think their bodies don't work and their baby will die." She also advised listeners, "If you can, stay away from hospital."
During the inquest, it was revealed that the parents had hired Smith specifically because she specialized in identifying warning signs that might require hospitalization. However, Smith reportedly told them that irregular breathing in newborns was common and that babies sometimes needed "time to land." The baby's father stated they trusted Smith due to her experience.
Smith denied her comments constituted clinical advice, asserting a doula's role is to provide emotional support. She indicated she had attended only six births without a midwife prior to Baby DH's birth. A video of another podcast was played where Smith criticized medical interventions for newborns, suggesting some babies need a minute or two to start breathing and reiterated advice to avoid hospitals.
Experts at the inquest, including Dr. Alison Teate, president of the Australian College of Midwives, and Professor of Midwifery Hannah Dahlen, commented on Smith's statements. Teate found it "awkward" that Smith spread medically inaccurate information and noted Smith's apparent lack of understanding regarding the benefits of skilled midwifery care and appropriate intervention. Dahlen described Smith's comments as "dangerous," particularly when delivered with the authority of a "birth worker."
The inquest also heard about the death of another newborn, Baby B, in December 2022, who died after developing neonatal ammonia and sepsis from a group B streptococcal infection following a home birth. The mother had reportedly insisted on a home birth despite concerns from health professionals.
Smith has not worked as a doula since the death of Baby DH. The inquest is ongoing.