A young Catholic priest is leaving his Colorado church after outraging parishioners with sermons that called them 'mooches' and were described as 'fire and brimstone.' The Rev. Daniel Ciucci announced last week that he would take a six-month sabbatical after Christmas, followed by a move to a new parish in July.
Ciucci is departing Most Precious Blood Catholic Church in south Denver after nearly 900 people signed a petition last year questioning his leadership. Angry parishioners accused Ciucci of harming the Catholic community with his dogmatic sermons and perceived unwillingness to listen to the congregation, The Denver Post reported.
Michelle Vogt, who grew up attending the church's Catholic school and had her children baptized at the parish, cited a specific Easter sermon as her breaking point. During the sermon, Ciucci claimed the church was being exploited by 'mooches' who used its resources without giving back. Vogt, who also worked at the parish as a teacher's aide, now plans to return to Mass at Most Precious Blood following intervention by Denver's new Archbishop James Golka.
In an email and YouTube video announcing his departure, Ciucci stated he was taking the sabbatical and moving with the 'encouragement and support' of Golka. He described the sabbatical as a 'gift' from the archbishop, who he said prioritizes the health and holiness of his priests. Ciucci mentioned crying during a meeting with Golka in June, acknowledging he had been carrying a significant pain.
Ciucci encouraged parishioners not to follow him to his new church, urging them instead to welcome back those who had left under his leadership. He reflected on his work with Jesus in freeing himself 'for people who have stormed out, who have caused drama, whose entrance into gossip has hurt the body of Christ here.'
Former parishioner David Thomas, who had previously left Ciucci's predecessor's church due to sermons focused on penance and hellfire, is undecided about returning. He expressed uncertainty about the direction Archbishop Golka might steer Denver's Catholic community, pointing to Golka's support for a Supreme Court case regarding state funding for Catholic preschools that refuse LGBTQ+ families and his appearance in a prayer with Donald Trump at the White House. Thomas stated he was unsure what to expect from Golka.
Archbishop Golka later said he was 'heartbroken' that his encounter at the White House had upset people. The Rev. Joshua Nailon Nyoni will serve as interim at Most Precious Blood until a permanent replacement for Ciucci is appointed.