Prosecutors allege a self-described sadist lured a mentally ill British woman to Florida to act as her "executioner," but she ultimately sought help after arriving in the United States, leading to her death. The trial of Dwain Hall, 54, began Monday in Ocala, Florida, where he faces charges of murder and kidnapping.

Hall, who worshipped the Egyptian god of death, allegedly manipulated Sonia Exelby, 32, a music tutor from Portsmouth, England. Exelby, who had a history of mental health struggles including bipolar disorder and bulimia, spent two years communicating with Hall on a hardcore fetish website. She reportedly offered to pay him to end her life, according to statements made by prosecutor Amy Berndt.

Exelby flew to Florida on October 10, 2025, to meet Hall. However, prosecutors claim she had a change of heart upon arrival and traveled with Hall to a remote Airbnb near Reddick. Despite her alleged change of mind, Hall is accused of proceeding with the murder, beating and stabbing Exelby to death before burying her body in a shallow grave. Her body was discovered with four stab wounds.

Exelby had emailed herself during the flight, expressing her fears and regret: "As soon as the wheels leave the ground, I wish I was home, I can't get off the plane, I want to beg for help so badly. Oh god, I feel so sick…why am I here, why?" she wrote.

Investigators found evidence, including bloodstained items sent to an associate, and recovered numerous photos and videos from Hall's phone that he attempted to delete. Prosecutors stated the evidence indicated Hall acted for his "own sadistic pleasure."

Four of Exelby's siblings traveled to the U.S. to attend the trial. Her sister, Gemma Isaj, testified about Exelby's struggles with mental illness and her fear of individuals preying on vulnerable people on suicide forums. Exelby's long-term partner, Stevie Hunt, also provided testimony remotely from the UK, describing Exelby's positive qualities and his efforts to protect her, including temporarily holding her passport.

Hall has pleaded not guilty to the charges. He will not face the death penalty if convicted, as British police withheld crucial evidence due to U.S. prosecutors' initial pursuit of capital punishment, a practice prohibited by law when evidence is provided by British forces.

The trial continues, with the case also being covered by a podcast titled "The Trial." Support is available for those affected by mental health issues and suicidal thoughts.