Yankees Bench Jazz Chisholm Jr. for Pivotal ALDS Game Amidst Inconsistent Performance

The New York Yankees have benched second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. for Game 3 of the American League Division Series, opting to start Anthony Volpe at the position. Manager Aaron Boone cited a desire for a spark and improved lineup balance as the impetus for the decision ahead of the pivotal Wednesday night game.

Chisholm's benching comes after a difficult Game 2 performance, which included a costly throwing error in the first inning and an overall 0-for-6 start to the ALDS. "Just felt like it," Boone said when asked about the decision. "I felt like I wanted to go with [Volpe] today."

Boone indicated that the decision was contemplated during the team's travel back on Monday night. The lineup change also saw José Caballero replace Ryan McMahon. Boone stated he had not spoken directly with Chisholm about being removed from the starting lineup for this crucial game.

Chisholm, who is a pending free agent, has had a tumultuous tenure with the Yankees. Despite possessing significant talent, including speed, athleticism, and power, his performance has been inconsistent throughout the season. He finished the regular season batting .231 with a .711 OPS, 19 home runs, and 41 stolen bases in 137 games. A late-season thumb injury and stint on the injured list opened the door for Volpe's call-up from Triple-A.

Volpe, who has been transitioning to second base after playing shortstop, is seen as a potential option at second base for the Yankees next season. Boone expressed confidence in Volpe's recent play, noting his contributions on both sides of the ball since his return.

"Just [hoping for a] spark again," Boone said. "I think Anthony has played well since coming up at the end of the year. Both sides of the ball, he’s done a good job. So, yeah, felt like it made some sense to get him in there tonight, a few more righties at least in the lineup tonight, give a little more balance."

Boone addressed Chisholm's critical first-inning throw in Game 2, which allowed a run to score. While Chisholm maintained he would make the same throw again, Boone suggested that athletes under pressure may respond differently and that the focus should be on consistent defensive execution. "I don’t think he should have thrown the ball," Boone said. "But when you throw the ball, you can always play catch at a high level, just because it’s late. More of an issue with making the throw and then being erratic."