A new plan to tackle youth unemployment in the United Kingdom proposes a "whole system reset" across the public sector, requiring billions of pounds in annual investment, according to a report by former minister Alan Milburn.
Milburn urged Andy Burnham to commit to this "multi-billion pound investment," warning that without "radical reforms," up to 1.27 million individuals under 25 could be classified as Neet (not in employment, education, or training) within five years. The report estimates that net savings from these reforms would not materialize until the 2036-37 fiscal year, totaling approximately £200 million.
The report identifies a widening gap in accessing entry-level positions as a key driver of the crisis, with youth employment rates falling by 4.3%—equivalent to 330,000 people—between December 2022 and the end of last year.
Critiques are leveled against recent Labour policies, including minimum wage increases, higher National Insurance contributions for employers, and new Employment Rights Act protections. The report states that wage costs for 18 to 20-year-olds have risen by 65% in the past five years, with increased NI contributions and a lowered threshold adding an estimated £800 annually per full-time worker. Milburn suggests a phased approach to lowering National Insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24 and proposes doubling the threshold for employers in retail and hospitality to pay NI for this age group when fiscal conditions permit.
The report also advises caution regarding Labour's pledge to align the minimum wage for 18 to 20-year-olds with the National Living Wage, recommending the Low Pay Commission assess the pace of this convergence with a focus on protecting youth employment. Additionally, it calls for consideration of the "potential impact on youth employment" of proposed rules targeting zero-hours contracts.
Beyond employment, the report addresses educational and health concerns contributing to youth disengagement. It notes a significant increase in persistent absence from school and highlights the impact of excessive screen time on young people's well-being. Recommendations include enhanced parental support through "family hubs," a new target for school readiness among reception-age pupils, and diagnostic assessments in Key Stage 3 to identify students at risk of becoming Neets. Schools would also be measured on their success in preparing pupils for the workforce, with a new performance metric to be introduced by 2028.
The report calls for a substantial increase in apprenticeships, aiming to rise from 172,000 in the past year to 270,000 within a decade. It also points to a rise in health conditions and disabilities among Neets, particularly mild mental health conditions, attributing this partly to the COVID-19 pandemic, social media, and loneliness. The report suggests immediate access to support through a new "digital front door" for the NHS and advocates for moving the responsibility for signing fit notes away from GPs by 2027.
Concerns are raised about the increasing number of young people claiming incapacity benefits like the Personal Independence Payment (PIP), which has more than doubled since 2012 and is projected to quadruple by 2037. Milburn argues that "crude cuts" are counterproductive, leading to greater costs in health, housing, or criminal justice. The proposed reforms include a new "Youth Allowance" for under-25s and an "opportunity guarantee" from the state, which could include government-subsidized jobs, further education, or cadetships. As a final measure, if a Neet individual cannot secure work, the state would be expected to provide and fund a six-month paid job with an employer. Young people are expected to engage with a named adviser within 14 days, develop a personalized plan within four weeks, and see substantive progress within four months, with persistent refusal to engage potentially leading to the loss of Youth Allowance benefits.