Sources close to former President Donald Trump are expressing private reservations about the new British Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, describing him as "dorky" and "not Trump's kind of guy." However, this assessment is juxtaposed with a public stance of offering Burnham a "clean slate" and a potential for a more constructive relationship than that experienced with former Prime Minister Keir Starmer.
The "special relationship" between the U.S. and the U.K. is navigating a period of significant global and bilateral challenges, including security concerns in Ukraine and Russia, economic disputes over tariffs and trade, and cultural divides on issues like immigration and free speech. Burnham, previously known primarily as the Mayor of Greater Manchester, has ascended to the premiership amidst these pressing matters.
Despite their differing life paths—Trump's Manhattan real estate background versus Burnham's traditional Labour Party rise—both leaders are seen as possessing an intuitive understanding of voters who feel unheard. They are also characterized by their willingness to trust their political instincts and build personal brands that can transcend party affiliation.
Shifting Diplomatic Approach
Keir Starmer's initial strategy with Trump involved a careful balancing act of flattery and quiet disagreement, prioritizing the preservation of the bilateral relationship. This approach, however, led to growing friction over issues such as Ukraine, energy policy, and China. Trump reportedly viewed Starmer as overly cautious and constrained by party orthodoxy, while Starmer came to see the White House as viewing allies as "negotiating counterparts, foils and scapegoats."
In contrast, Trump and his team have publicly adopted a more cordial tone towards Burnham. Trump has described their initial conversation as "very good" and emphasized the importance of revitalizing the U.S.-U.K. relationship. Even Trump's unsolicited advice on expanding North Sea oil and gas production was framed as "friendly encouragement."
Privately, the sentiment within Trump's circle is a hope that Burnham will be a pragmatist focused on "the art of the deal." Washington is reportedly observing Burnham's ministerial appointments, with the impression that he is selecting "practical figures" signaling an intent to govern rather than adhere to old Labour platforms.
Emerging Concerns
The selection of Ed Miliband as Foreign Secretary, however, has emerged as a principal source of anxiety for the Trump administration. Officials reportedly view Miliband as being at odds with Trump's worldview on critical issues such as energy, climate policy, Iran, and the role of international institutions. This potential point of contention is seen as a more likely flashpoint than a direct conflict between Trump and Burnham themselves.
Despite these private concerns, the public reaction from Trump's orbit has been measured, a departure from the "scathing criticism" that characterized the Starmer era. The message, for now, appears to be that Burnham is being judged on his actions and the counsel he receives.
One source within Trump's world suggested that Burnham's "friendly guy" demeanor offers a political advantage over Starmer's perceived stiffness. Yet, the same source cautioned that Burnham would ultimately face the same governance challenges, including public unhappiness and resistance to necessary but difficult policy changes, such as cuts to welfare programs. The source also noted that figures like Nigel Farage remain on Trump's allies' radar, suggesting an ongoing watchfulness of the broader British political landscape.