Justice Clarence Thomas voiced concern Monday that the Supreme Court’s refusal to hear a case challenging a California law could pave the way for states to compel private citizens to express government-favored viewpoints. Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented from the court’s decision not to review a case brought by a California physician.

The case centered on California's requirement that physicians complete continuing education courses that include instruction on implicit bias. The physician, Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, and the nonprofit Do No Harm argued that the mandate forced instructors to convey a message they disagreed with, violating the First Amendment.

Thomas wrote that the First Amendment applies when the government compels private speakers to communicate its viewpoint. He argued that allowing the California law to stand could allow the government-speech doctrine to be used as "a cover for censorship" or "a cloak for compelled speech."

California contended that instructors were not required to personally endorse the theory of implicit bias and could express disagreement. The state maintained that it must have broad authority to dictate continuing medical education requirements for license retention.

The Ninth Circuit had previously ruled that the state’s extensive regulation of the medical profession turned the continuing education courses into government speech, thus shielding them from First Amendment scrutiny. Thomas, however, disputed this characterization, stating that the requirement left instructors no choice but to affirm the state's view on implicit bias.

Thomas suggested that the implications of this decision could extend beyond the medical field, questioning whether states could compel speakers at other professional conferences to adopt specific viewpoints. He argued that this application of the Ninth Circuit's logic could convert private speech into unprotected government speech.

Justice Neil Gorsuch also dissented from the court’s decision not to hear the case, although his specific reasoning was not detailed. The Supreme Court’s decision leaves the Ninth Circuit’s ruling in place without definitively settling the First Amendment question.

A spokesperson for Do No Harm stated that the organization was disappointed the Supreme Court did not take the case but remained encouraged that some justices recognized the First Amendment issues at stake. The group vowed to continue advocating for free speech rights.