The Supreme Court has declined to hear a case involving a California doctor who argued that a state law compelling her to lecture on "implicit bias" theory violated her First Amendment rights. Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas were the only justices to vote to hear the case, with the majority apparently accepting California's argument that the mandate is permissible because medicine is a heavily regulated profession.

Dr. Azadeh Khatibi contended that being required to present the theory of implicit bias as fact amounted to compelled speech, forcing her to adopt the government's viewpoint. Critics of the ruling, including Justice Thomas, warned that the court's decision not to intervene could embolden those seeking to restrict or compel speech. The New York Post noted that there is a lack of evidence proving that implicit bias training improves patient outcomes.

This case arises amid a broader trend of states implementing "implicit bias" training requirements. Maryland passed a similar law in April conditioning medical license renewals on such training, and a nearly identical law took effect in Virginia in July. Illinois will implement a specialized implicit bias course for maternal health starting January 1.

The trend extends beyond the medical field. A bill proposed in New York would mandate implicit bias training for all state employees. Additionally, Colorado's Kelly Loving Act, which took effect last month, designates a person's chosen name as a protected aspect of their identity, similar to race or religion, requiring public employees to respect transgender individuals' chosen names and imposing legal repercussions on businesses that do not comply.

California is also considering Assembly Bill 1803, which, starting in 2028, would mandate anti-hate speech training for all businesses with five or more employees. The New York Post questioned whether the Supreme Court would similarly decline to hear challenges to such laws.

Justice Thomas expressed concern that the court's reluctance to defend the First Amendment in this instance could encourage further speech restrictions. The article also pointed to the recent elections, which have resulted in Democrats controlling both legislative houses and the governorship in 22 states, suggesting a potential increase in such mandates.