Former Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has drawn criticism for her refusal to release a statement given to police as part of Operation Branchform. Rachael Hamilton, Deputy Leader of the Scottish Conservatives, contends that Sturgeon's decision continues a pattern of secrecy and evasiveness that characterized her tenure as First Minister.
Hamilton noted Sturgeon's previous commitment to transparency, including a pledge to be the most accessible individual to hold the office, a promise Hamilton asserts has aged poorly. The criticism extends to Sturgeon's handling of the pandemic inquiry, where she was revealed to have routinely deleted WhatsApp messages. Hamilton stated that Sturgeon's current behavior, by refusing to publish her police statement, fuels suspicion among Scots regarding her knowledge of and involvement in matters concerning her husband, Peter Murrell.
Sturgeon has indicated that her statement will remain private, citing advice from her lawyer. Hamilton characterized this stance as an attempt by Sturgeon, who is reportedly enjoying life in London, to distance herself from scandal and make the issues disappear. Hamilton argued that secrecy, evasiveness, spin, and bluster were hallmarks of Sturgeon's time as First Minister.
Hamilton called for a robust and independent inquiry into the scandal, suggesting that current First Minister John Swinney is also hesitant to grant one due to fear of what might be uncovered. Hamilton believes that despite attempts by the SNP to obstruct the revelation of truth about the culture that enabled Murrell's alleged crimes, the truth will eventually emerge, further damaging Sturgeon's legacy.