Strictly Come Dancing Judges Reportedly Considering Quitting; Head Judge Shirley Ballas Eyed for 'Dancing With The Stars'
Amidst contract negotiations and reports of all four judges potentially leaving the BBC show, speculation mounts that head judge Shirley Ballas could transition to the American version of the competition.
Strictly Come Dancing is facing potential upheaval as all four of its judges—Shirley Ballas, Craig Revel Horwood, Anton Du Beke, and Motsi Mabuse—are reportedly considering not renewing their contracts, which conclude at the end of the current season. This situation has led to concerns among BBC bosses, particularly with the departure of hosts Claudia Winkleman and Tess Daly. Adding to the speculation, head judge Shirley Ballas is being eyed for a move to the American counterpart, 'Dancing With The Stars' (DWTS).
Ballas, 66, who has been the head judge since 2017, is recognized for her technical expertise and has a growing presence in the U.S. She recently served as a judge on the DWTS spin-off 'The Next Pro' alongside her son, professional dancer Mark Ballas. Brand and culture expert Nick Ede believes a move to DWTS could be a significant career boost for Ballas, potentially making her an even bigger star in America. Ede noted that while 'Strictly' offers significant visibility, leaving at the height of her popularity could be a strategic career move, similar to Alesha Dixon's transition.
Speculation about Ballas's potential departure has been fueled by reports that she may wish to relocate to the U.S. to spend more time with her grandchildren. Insiders suggest that while the BBC counted on the judges' continuity, their contracts will require renegotiation, and the judges may seek different terms. Ballas herself has previously hinted at a desire to be more present for her son and grandchildren, regretting her past career-focused intensity.
Any mass exodus of judges would represent a significant gamble for the BBC, as the judging panel is considered a key element of 'Strictly's' success. However, it could also present an opportunity to refresh the show's format and attract new audiences. Finding replacements with comparable chemistry and credibility would be a considerable challenge.
Previous contract negotiations have seen disputes over pay. In 2023, the judges reportedly sought an 11% pay increase, which was met with resistance from BBC bosses. While they ultimately received a smaller raise of 3-5%, the issue highlights potential friction over compensation. A show source indicated that further significant pay raises are unlikely, especially given recent declines in viewing figures.
Amidst these rumors, former 'Strictly' professional James Jordan has publicly called for a shake-up of the judging panel, suggesting that some judges should be replaced. Jordan expressed that the judging dynamic has become predictable and that the panel needs a refresh to improve the show's current appeal.