South Yorkshire Police have stated that their officers' actions were justified after footage emerged showing them using batons and Tasers on a group of teenage girls in Rotherham. The force insists the use of force during the incident was "proportionate, necessary and justified."
The incident, which occurred over the weekend, drew widespread criticism after a video was shared on social media, with many accusing the police of using undue force.
The video shows an officer arguing with a group of girls before telling them they were being dispersed for a breach of the peace. When one girl pushed the officer, they were shoved backward. The situation escalated as more girls surrounded the officer, who then drew his baton. Another officer was also pushed and appeared to strike one of the teenagers.
Two additional officers arrived and deployed Tasers, ordering the group to move back. At least six officers were visible in the clip.
South Yorkshire Police confirmed they have reviewed all available footage, including body-worn video, and officer statements. A spokesperson noted that the widely circulated clip shows only a fraction of a longer police response to a 999 call reporting a fight involving numerous young people. "Having viewed the clip in isolation, it is understandable that local and wider communities have some concerns," the spokesperson said.
The force initiated a review, including requesting a peer review from another police force, despite the incident not meeting the criteria for independent assessment. This review upheld the initial determination that the use of force was justified. While the review identified an "opportunity for learning around de-escalation," it concluded that, considering the events before and during the clip, the force used was necessary to ensure everyone's safety.