SNP ministers have been warned that action must be taken to address Scotland's crisis of young people not in education, employment, or training (NEETs), following a review advocating for a UK-wide overhaul. Nearly one in six young Scots aged 16 to 24 are classified as NEET, a rate higher than other parts of the UK. The review, authored by Alan Milburn, suggests its recommendations should be applied across the UK, prompting the UK Government to call for collaboration with Scottish ministers to tackle the issue.

However, a senior SNP minister repeatedly declined to confirm if she believed Scotland faced a NEETs crisis, stating that she dislikes the term as it is a "label." Douglas Alexander, Scottish Secretary, highlighted that around one in six young Scots are not in work, education, or training, calling it an "economic catastrophe and a moral failure" if a generation is left behind. He welcomed Milburn's report, which outlines earlier support and real opportunities for young people, and expressed a desire for Scotland to benefit from this approach.

The Milburn review proposes recommendations spanning education, health, and welfare. While some measures, such as a guaranteed job for those unemployed for 18 months, could apply nationwide, others concerning the benefits system may not directly apply in Scotland due to devolved powers. For instance, a new Additional Cost Allowance intended to replace the health element of Personal Independence Payment is not directly transferable as this benefit has been devolved and replaced by the adult disability payment.

Milburn's report notes that while the underlying problem is UK-wide, the institutional solutions will differ because education, skills, health, and local government are devolved matters in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. He advises devolved governments to consider how the principles can fit within their own institutions and existing services.

A Youth Employment Index from PwC indicated Scotland's NEET rate at 16 percent, higher than any other UK region, with Labour estimating this figure affects 90,000 young people in Scotland. Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra described the situation as a "moral failing" and asserted that this must change, proposing a "new settlement for young people" including subsidized jobs and new legal rights to opportunity.

The Scottish Conservatives pointed out that the review found insufficient welfare spending directed towards helping young people find employment. Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay urged John Swinney to consider the report ahead of his budget, criticizing what he called "soaring welfare spending" and "punishing taxes" under the SNP government.

Sandy Begbie, chief executive of Scottish Financial Enterprise, urged the Scottish government to adopt a constructive approach to the recommendations, prioritizing young people who have missed opportunities. He suggested revisiting Scotland's existing Young Person's Guarantee to match the ambition of the Milburn report.

When questioned, SNP Education Secretary Mairi McAllan attributed the difficulties young people face in securing entry-level jobs to "underlying economic conditions" across the UK, rather than solely to education or social security issues. She reiterated her discomfort with the term "NEETs," preferring to focus on the individuals involved. McAllan also stated that the employment rate for 16-24-year-olds is higher in Scotland than in England and affirmed willingness to collaborate with the UK Government for the benefit of young people in Scotland.

First Minister John Swinney acknowledged the review as a "substantial contribution" and stated the government would consider its findings. He noted that while some elements might align with Scottish approaches, like expanded vocational qualifications, potential "significant financial implications" for the Scottish Government would require detailed examination, contingent on the UK Government's response.