Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood's proposed immigration reforms have been criticized as a "farce" following a vote by Labour MPs against permanently barring individuals who arrive illegally from obtaining British citizenship. In a further setback, MPs also rejected tougher measures Mahmood had initially sought before being compelled to moderate them.
The controversy arose when the Conservatives, through their shadow home secretary Chris Philp, put forward two amendments to the Immigration and Asylum Bill during its final reading in the House of Commons. One amendment proposed a lifetime ban on British citizenship for asylum seekers and migrants arriving illegally, such as via small boat crossings. However, Labour MPs voted against this measure.
Additionally, Labour MPs voted down a second Conservative amendment that would have required migrants to wait ten years before being eligible for the right to remain in Britain. Under the bill as passed, a significant number of low-skilled migrants, including foreign care workers, will be eligible to apply for Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) after five years. ILR grants indefinite rights to live, work, and claim benefits in the UK.
Mahmood had initially proposed a 15-year waiting period for such migrants but was reportedly forced to soften the proposals due to opposition from within her own party's backbenchers.
Philp described the situation as "a complete farce," stating that the public would expect illegal immigrants to be barred from citizenship. He criticized Labour for what he called prioritizing illegal immigrants over the British public. Philp also pointed to the government's record, noting that out of 88,000 individuals who had crossed the Channel illegally since the Labour government took office, only about 6,000 had been removed, with over 90 percent allowed to stay. He argued that the bill represented only minor improvements and that true border control would require leaving the European Convention on Human Rights and dismantling the current legal framework for illegal migration.
In related developments, Mahmood's department will introduce an amendment to allow for the deportation of rejected asylum seekers and illegal migrants within hours of their appeals failing, closing a loophole that currently provides a minimum five-day grace period. This period has often been used by failed asylum seekers to initiate last-minute legal challenges.
Following the debate, Mahmood stated that the legislation aims to "restore order and control to our borders by bearing down on illegal entry and swiftly removing those with no right to be here." The bill passed with a vote of 294 in favor to 94 against.