Sanders, Khanna Rally for California Billionaire Tax Amidst Fierce Opposition
Progressive Democrats advocate for a one-time 5% wealth tax, clashing with Governor Newsom and wealthy donors.
Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Ro Khanna are campaigning in California to garner support for a proposed one-time 5% tax on the wealth of the state's billionaires. The initiative, which aims to generate revenue to offset federal Medi-Cal cuts, faces significant opposition, including from Gov. Gavin Newsom and substantial campaign spending by wealthy individuals and groups.
Khanna has characterized his disagreement with Newsom on the issue as a fundamental difference in party direction, questioning whether the Democratic party will prioritize working-class constituents or wealthy donors. "He [Newsom] doesn't want to offend some of the billionaires who he wants to finance his campaigns, and that's the question: Are we going to be a party for the working class? Are we going to be beholden to our donors?" Khanna stated, also challenging Newsom to a public debate.
Newsom, while expressing respect for Sanders, fundamentally disagrees with the proposed state measure. A spokesperson for the governor stated, "The Governor supports a national tax on billionaires and is proud to stand with teachers, firefighters, reproductive health clinics, and others in opposing this poorly written state measure that will harm California.” Newsom has instead proposed a national billionaire tax focused on loans taken against assets.
Tech investors have voiced strong opposition, with Vinod Khosla warning that top wealth creators would depart the state and Mark Cuban suggesting Khanna misunderstands business. However, Khanna cited Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, who stated he is "perfectly fine" with paying the tax and chose to live in Silicon Valley regardless of tax implications.
Opponents have funded a robust campaign against the initiative, with the organization Building a Better California raising over $252 million, primarily from billionaires such as Sergey Brin, John Doerr, and Eric Schmidt. The group argues that the tax could lead to a decline in tax revenue and potentially trigger wealth taxes on non-billionaires. The California Farm Bureau, part of the opposition coalition, expressed concern that the measure could become "just another tax on farmers and ranchers."
Conversely, the primary group supporting the measure, Yes on 40, has raised approximately $32.4 million, largely from Service Employees International Union-United Healthcare Workers West and affiliated organizations. SEIU-UHW chief of staff Suzanne Jimenez indicated that the campaign anticipated being outspent, viewing the opposition's spending as potentially counterproductive.
Some labor organizations, including California Professional Firefighters and California Teachers Association, oppose the tax. During a press call, Sanders questioned the viability of a ballot item winning when facing such significant financial opposition from a few billionaires, asking, "Do you still have a democracy in this country, or will billionaires rule?"
Khanna noted that the debate over taxing the ultra-wealthy is a national issue that will continue to unfold in current and future political landscapes.