A significant power struggle is reportedly underway at CBS News between newly appointed editor-in-chief Bari Weiss and network president Tom Cibrowski, creating what sources describe as a "Cold War" environment that is hamstringing the newsroom. Employees feel caught between two conflicting editorial visions, leading to day-to-day confusion and a reluctance to act.
Weiss, who joined as editor-in-chief last October, has been tasked by David Ellison, CEO of CBS parent Paramount Skydance, with steering the network toward a more centrist approach with a focus on hard news and enterprise reporting. Her background as an opinion writer and editor has led her to advocate for a more analytical and intellectually driven news agenda. She has reportedly pushed for coverage on topics such as former Dr. Anthony Fauci's Senate hearings and the impact of heatwaves in Europe.
In contrast, Cibrowski, a veteran television executive with a history at ABC News, is said to favor softer, more mainstream content appealing to Middle America. This includes segments like weather reports and feel-good animal videos, a style more aligned with his previous role producing programs like "Good Morning America."
The differing philosophies have created a chasm, with some staffers feeling that Cibrowski's team, which includes several former ABC News executives, is prioritizing lighter fare over Weiss's agenda. This alleged "mini ABC mafia" is perceived by some as undermining Weiss's efforts and promoting a "news you can use" approach that clashes with her more intellectual take.
Sources close to Cibrowski, however, suggest he respects Weiss and finds her ideas intelligent. The conflict is reportedly not characterized by overt hostility, but rather a lack of clear direction. Employees are waiting for one side to emerge victorious so they can proceed with their work.
Ratings are seen as a crucial factor that could determine the outcome of this internal conflict. The upcoming fall season, particularly the performance of "60 Minutes," is considered a potential litmus test for Weiss's tenure. Meanwhile, Cibrowski faces pressure as "CBS Mornings" and "CBS Evening News" have struggled to maintain viewership, recently falling into last place.
This past summer saw notable turnover among CBS News's star correspondents, including the departures of Scott Pelley, Anderson Cooper, Sharyn Alfonsi, and Cecilia Vega. Cibrowski has made changes, such as appointing Norah O'Donnell to co-anchor "CBS Mornings" alongside Gayle King and Nate Burleson, and is reportedly planning further format adjustments inspired by MSNBC's "Morning Joe."
Compounding the situation is a leadership structure where Weiss oversees editorial operations and reports to Ellison, while Cibrowski manages TV operations and reports to CBS CEO George Cheeks, who also reports to Ellison. The two executives reportedly maintain separate public relations teams and occupy different office floors, further highlighting the division.
Critics suggest that Weiss, who is described as stretched thin, may lack the managerial experience for the television news environment. Her "fail fast" startup approach is seen as ill-suited for the delicate process of viewer retention in broadcast television, where changes typically unfold over multiple seasons. Staffers complain that Weiss and her top lieutenant, Charles Forelle, do not hold people accountable for executing directives, leading to a culture of superficial agreement without action.
Despite the internal friction, a CBS spokesperson has dismissed reports of conflict as "baseless gossip," asserting that the newsroom is operating collaboratively and expressing excitement for the new season of "60 Minutes."