Police Officers Remain on Duty Amid Abuse Allegations

Nineteen police officers are currently assigned to restricted duties while facing allegations of domestic or sexual offenses, according to a report obtained by The Mail on Sunday. In total, 140 officers are on restricted duties, with 121 facing accusations including assault and road traffic offenses. One officer has been on restricted duties for nearly six years.

These findings have drawn criticism from political figures who question the handling of such serious allegations. Pauline McNeill, Scottish Labour’s justice spokeswoman, stated that the figures "raise serious questions" and emphasized the need for public confidence in the thoroughness of investigations and transparency from Police Scotland.

The internal Scottish Police Authority (SPA) report, dated September 15, indicates that of the 140 officers on restricted duties, eight are accused of sexual offenses and 11 of domestic offenses. Other allegations include assault (both on and off duty), road traffic offenses, data protection violations, and discreditable conduct. Thirty-two of the officers involved are women.

The SPA report clarifies that restricted duties are not a punitive measure but are implemented when risk assessment suggests restrictions are necessary, but suspension is not warranted. Such duties can involve removal from operational or public-facing roles.

Police Scotland Chief Constable Jo Farrell recently stated that 45 officers are suspended over claims of violence against women and girls, adding that those who commit crimes should "feel the full force of the law." However, the revelation that some officers remain at work while under investigation has led to calls for a consistent approach.

Nicola Love, Rape Crisis Scotland external affairs manager, commented on the need for a uniform process for handling domestic and sexual abuse reports, stating, "It shouldn’t be suspension for one and desk duty for another." She also noted concerns about internal investigations potentially taking years to conclude, highlighting a six-year case as particularly concerning.

Scottish Conservative justice spokesman Stephen Kerr echoed these sentiments, asserting that "Victims of domestic and sexual abuse deserve to know that allegations are acted on properly, whoever is accused."

Police Scotland maintains that decisions regarding suspension or restriction of officers are based on comprehensive risk assessments tailored to the specific circumstances of each case.

Previously, former police officer Campbell Petrie was convicted last month of sex crimes against two women. He was suspended following his arrest in 2023 and retired from the force in December 2025.