Paul Ince, who joined Manchester United in 1989, has voiced strong criticism regarding the club's recent midfield acquisitions and overall management strategy. Reflecting on his own experience at Old Trafford, Ince highlighted the stark contrast between the recruitment process under Sir Alex Ferguson and the current approach.
"When I joined United, Sir Alex said to me: ‘I watched you for two years before I decided to buy you.’ Two years!" Ince recalled. "These players are one-season wonders and go for £100m. What? I don't get it, I really don't. The money’s going really crazy."
He specifically pointed to the club's significant outlay on new midfielders, citing Andrey Santos, who reportedly cost £50 million and had minimal playing time at Chelsea, and Carlos Baleba, who incurred a £70 million fee and faced injury issues. Ince contrasted this with the perceived value and impact of midfielders from his era, such as Roy Keane and Bryan Robson, suggesting they would command astronomical fees in today's market.
Ince also addressed the managerial instability at Manchester United since Ferguson's departure in 2013. "Since Fergie left in 2013, we've gone through about seven or eight managers. The recruitment has been poor. The people upstairs have been poor. The way they’ve run the club has been poor, so what do you expect?"
While acknowledging the club's struggles, Ince expressed hope for current manager Michael Carrick. "We can’t keep changing managers. We've got to stick with one, and I think Carrick deserves that chance," he stated, questioning whether Carrick is fully prepared for the role but emphasizing the need for stability.
Ince's reflections also touched upon the changing nature of professional football, including player behavior and media engagement. He lamented the perceived decline in on-field camaraderie and the increased focus on individual player concerns over team cohesion. "The characters are going out of the game," Ince observed. "Players are more concerned about themselves and what people think. Everyone feels so precious about what they've got to do and what they can't do."
Recalling his own departure from the club in 1995, Ince mentioned that Ferguson's decision to sanction his move to Inter Milan, partly due to concerns over his 'Guvnor' image and the emergence of Nicky Butt, was a pivotal moment. Despite Ferguson's later attempt to persuade him to stay, Ince felt the decision was final.
Beyond football, Ince participated in a campaign by the British Heart Foundation and Sky Bet to address fears surrounding the use of defibrillators, drawing from a personal experience witnessing Glenn Hoddle's cardiac arrest. He stressed the simplicity and importance of learning CPR and using defibrillator machines to save lives.